“Give to Caesar what belongs to Caesar, and to God what belongs to God.” (Mk. 12:17)
Tuesday, November 3, 2026
To Caesar What is Caesar's and to God What is God's!
“Give to Caesar what belongs to Caesar, and to God what belongs to God.” (Mk. 12:17)
Sunday, November 1, 2026
All Saints Day Meditations on Paradise --Saint Alphonsus Liguori
I. Oh, happy are we if we suffer with patience on earth the troubles of this present life ! Distress of circumstances, fears, bodily infirmities, persecutions, and crosses of every kind, will one day all come to an end ; and if we be saved, they will all become for us subjects of joy and glory in paradise: Your sorrow (says the Savior, to encourage us) shall be turned into joy. ("Tristitia vestra vertetur in gaudium."—John, xvi. 20.) So great are the delights of paradise, that they can neither be explained nor understood by us mortals : Eye hath not seen (says the Apostle), nor ear heard, neither hath it entered into the heart of man, what things God hath prepared for those who love Him. ("Oculus non vidit, nec auris audivit, nec in cor hominis ascendit, quae praeparavit Deus iis qui diligunt illum." —1 Cor. ii. 9.) Beauties like the beauties of paradise, eye hath never seen ; harmonies like unto the harmonies of paradise, ear hath never heard ; nor hath ever human heart gained the comprehension of the joys which God hath prepared for those that love him. Beautiful is the sight of a landscape adorned with hills, plains, woods, and views of the sea. Beautiful is the sight of a garden abounding with fruit, flowers, and fountains. Oh, how much more beautiful is paradise !
Preparation for Death
We are unable to understand the joys of paradise, because we have no conception but of the joys of this earth. If horses were capable of reasoning, and they knew that their master had prepared a grand banquet, they would imagine that it could consist of nothing else but of good hay, oats, and barley, because horses have no notion of food except such as this. Even thus do we form notions of the joys of paradise. It is beautiful to see, on a summer's night, the sky all glittering with stars; and how delightful, in the time of spring, to stand on the sea-coast when the sea is calm, so that the rocks within can be seen all covered with seaweed, and the fishes which glide nimbly by; and it is very delightful to be in a garden full of fruit trees and flowers, surrounded by running fountains, and with birds which fly about and sing as they fly. Some might say, " Oh, what a paradise!" What a paradise? Do you say, What a paradise? Very different are the joys of paradise. In order to understand something, although obscurely, of paradise, let us remember that the Omnipotent God is there, Who is ever engaged in delighting the souls which love Hun. S. Bernard says, Dost thou wish to know what there is in paradise? "There is nothing that thou wouldst not have, but everything that thou wouldst have, there."
O God, what will the soul say upon entering into that blessed kingdom? Let us imagine that some young girl and some youth, who, having consecrated themselves to the love of Jesus Christ, are dying; the hour of death having arrived, the spirit quits this earth. The soul is presented before the judgment seat, the Judge embraces her, and makes known to her that she is saved. Her guardian angel comes to meet her and rejoices with her; she thanks the angel for the assistance given to her, and the angel then says, " Take courage, beautiful soul, rejoice, for thou art now saved. Come and see the face of thy Lord." Behold, the soul now passes through the clouds, the heavens, and the stars. She enters heaven. O God, what will she say when she enters for the first time that blessed country, and when she looks for the first time upon that city of delights? The angels and the saints will come to meet her, and they will welcome her with shouts of joy. What consolation she will have in meeting again those relations or friends who entered paradise before her. The soul will then wish to kneel before them and to worship them, but they will say to her, " See thou do it not, for I am thy fellow-servant." (Rev. xxii. 9.) Then the soul will be led to Jesus, Who will receive her as His spouse, and will say to her, " Come with Me from Lebanon, My spouse." (Cant. iv. 8.) Rejoice greatly, My spouse, all thy tears, griefs, and fears are now for ever ended, receive the everlasting crown which I have obtained for thee by My Blood. Jesus Himself will then lead her to receive the blessing of His Divine Father, Who, embracing her, will bless her, saying, " Enter thou into the joy of Thy Lord." (S. Matt, xxv. 21.) And He will bless her with the same beatitude which He Himself enjoys.
Affections and Prayers.
Behold, my God, at Thy feet one ungrateful, who was created by Thee for heaven, but who, often for miserable pleasures, has renounced it to Thy face, and has chosen to be condemned to hell. But I hope that even now Thou hast forgiven all the injuries that I have done, of which I repent over and over again, and will continue to repent until death. I desire that Thou ever wouldst renew my pardon. But, O my God, although Thou hast already pardoned me, it will yet be ever true that I had no disposition to embitter Thee, my Redeemer, Who, to bring me to Thy kingdom, hadst given Thy life. But may Thy compassion, O my Jesus, be ever praised and blessed, that with so great patience hast borne with me, and in place of chastisements hast increased toward me graces, lights, and calls. I see, my dear Savior, that Thou didst will my special salvation, and in Thy country to love Thee eternally, but Thou desirest that first I should love Thee on earth. Yes, I will love Thee, and this, even were there no heaven, while I live, with all my soul and with all my might. It is enough for me to know that Thou, my God, desirest to be loved by me. My Jesus, assist me with Thy grace and do not abandon me. My soul is eternal; therefore, it is certain that for ever either I must love Thee or hate Thee. No, I will love Thee for ever, and I will love Thee much in this life and in the next. Dispose of me as it pleaseth Thee, chasten me here as Thou wilt, but do not deprive me of Thy love, and afterwards do with me as it may please Thee. My Jesus, Thy merits are my hope. I place all my trust in Thy intercession. Thou didst deliver me from hell when I was in sin; now that I desire Thee, do Thou save me and make me holy.
In heaven there is no more weakness, nor poverty, nor trouble; no longer any succession of day and night, nor of cold and heat; there, it is perpetual day, ever serene; a continual spring, ever delicious. There will be there no more persecutions, or envyings. All will love tenderly, and each one will rejoice in the good of the other as if it were his own. There are no more fears, since the soul, confirmed in grace, can no longer sin and lose its God. " Behold, I make all things new." All are new, and are consoling and satisfying. " There is everything that one can desire." There, shall the sight be satisfied by gazing at that city. " The perfection of beauty." (Lam. ii. 15.) What delight would it be to behold a city, where the pavement of its streets would be of crystal, the palaces of silver with ceilings of gold, and the whole adorned with festoons of flowers? Oh, how much more beautiful will be the heavenly city! What will it be to behold those citizens clad in royal robes, since all are Icings; as S. Augustine said, "As many citizens, so many kings." What will it be then to see the Divine Lamb, the Spouse Jesus! The sense of smell will be satisfied with the odours of heaven; the sense of hearing by celestial harmonies. What will it be to hear all the saints and angels singing in chorus the glories of God! " They will be always praising Thee." (Ps. lxxxiv. 4.) In short, all the delights are there that can possibly be desired.
But these delights now mentioned are the lesser blessings of heaven. The good which makes heaven is the Highest Good, which is God. S. Augustine says that " all which we look for are two syllables, Deus, God." The reward which the Lord promises us does not consist only in the beauties, the harmonies, and the other joys of that blessed City, for the chief reward there is GOD HIMSELF, that is, to see and to love God face to face. " I am .... thy exceeding great Reward." (Gen. xv. I.) S. Augustine says, That if God were to show Himself to the lost, immediately hell itself would be changed into a pleasant paradise; and he continues, That if a departed soul did choose between seeing God and abiding in the punishments of hell, and not seeing God and being liberated from it, "it would rather choose to see God and to be in these pains."
This joy of seeing and loving God face to face cannot be understood by us in this life, but we can infer something of what it is like, knowing that this Divine love is so sweet, that even in this life it has lifted from earth the souls of the saints. The holy martyrs, through its sweetness, were joyous in the midst of their very torments. S. Augustine records, that S. Vincent, whilst he was being tortured, so spake that "it seemed one who suffered, and another who spoke." S. Laurence, whilst on a gridiron, scorned the tyrant, "Turn me and eat me." Yes, says S. Augustine, because S. Laurence, inflamed with this fire of Divine love, did not feel the burning. Moreover, how sweet it proves to a sinner in this life, even the weeping over his sins. Whence S. Bernard says, " If it be so sweet to weep for thee, what must it be to rejoice for thee?" What sweetness then does not the soul experience, to whom in prayer is disclosed by a ray of light, the Divine goodness, the mercies experienced, and the love which has been and still is shed upon it, by Jesus Christ. And although in this life we see not God as He really is, for we see Him but obscurely. " Now we see through a glass, darkly; but then face to face." (i Cor. xiii. 12.) At this present time we have a bandage before our eyes, and God is hidden under the veil of faith, and He allows us not to see Him. But what will it be, when the bandage is taken away from the eyes and the veil is raised, and we can see God face to face? Then shall we see how lovely, how glorious, how just, how perfect, how amiable, how loving He is.
Affections and Prayers.
Oh, my Highest Good, I am that miserable one who has turned away from Thee, and has renounced Thy love, so that I am not worthy either to see Thee or to love Thee. But Thou art He, Who through compassion for me, hadst no compassion upon Thyself, but condemnedst Thyself to die of shamed grief upon the accursed tree. Thy death, indeed, gives me hope that one day I shall see and enjoy Thy face, and then I shall love Thee with all my strength. But now that I stand in danger of losing Thee for ever, now that I find that I have already lost Thee through my sins, what shall I do in the life which remains to me? Shall I continue to offend Thee? No, my Jesus, I detest with entire hatred the offences which I have committed. It grieves me in the greatest degree that I have injured Thee, and I love thee with all my heart. Wilt Thou cast away from Thee a soul which repents and loves Thee? No, truly I know what Thou hast said that Thou knowest not how, my loved Redeemer, to cast away any one who comes as a penitent to Thy feet. " Him that cometh unto Me, I will in no wise cast out." (S. John vi. 37.) My Jesus, I leave all and turn to Thee, and embrace Thee, and unite Thee to my heart. Do Thou embrace me, and unite me to Thy heart. I dare so to speak, since I speak to and treat with Infinite Goodness. I speak to that God who willed to die for my sake. My Beloved Savior, give me hope in Thy love.
For ever then will that blessed soul, enjoy that happiness which, through all eternity, at every moment will be for ever new, as if that moment was the first in which it enjoyed it. It will ever enjoy that happiness and will ever obtain it; ever thirsting and ever satisfied; ever satisfied and ever thirsting. Yes, since the desire of heaven brings no pain, and the fulfilment of it brings no weariness. In short, as the lost are vessels of wrath, so the blessed are vessels of joy. S. Teresa says that, even in this world, when God brings a soul into " the banqueting house," where it partakes of this Divine love, He renders it so happily inebriated, that it loses the affection for all earthly things. But in entering heaven, as David says, how much more perfectly shall it "drink of Thy pleasures as out of the river." (Ps. xxxvi. 8.) It will happen then, that the soul, beholding so openly, and embracing the highest good, will remain so inebriated with love, that delightfully it will lose itself in God; that is, will perfectly forget itself, and will not think of anything else from that moment than to love, praise, and bless that Infinite Good which it possesses.
When, therefore, the crosses of this life afflict us, let us comfort ourselves, and bear them patiently with the hope of heaven. S. Mary of Egypt being asked at the end of her life how she had been able to endure living so many years in that desert, answered, " In the hope of heaven." Let us also, when we find ourselves straightened by the miseries of this present life, raise our eyes to heaven, and console ourselves by sighing and saying, " Heaven, heaven." Let us consider that if we are faithful to God, shall end one day, all these pains, miseries, and fears, and we shall be received into that blessed country, where we shall be fully happy, whilst God shall be God. Behold, the saints are expecting us; and Jesus stands with a crown in His hand to make us kings of that eternal kingdom.
Affections and Prayers.
My beloved Savior, Thou hast taught me to pray, "Thy kingdom come." Thus now do I pray to Thee, may Thy kingdom come in my soul, that Thou mayest wholly possess it, and that it may possess Thee, the Highest Good. O my Jesus, Thou hast spared nothing to save me, and to gain my love; save me, therefore, and may it be my salvation to love Thee for ever in this life and in the next. I have so often turned away from Thee, and with all this Thou causest me to know that Thou wilt not disdain to embrace me in heaven through all eternity with as great love as if I had never caused Thee offence. And knowing this, shall I be able to love any other save Thee, seeing that Thou desirest to give me heaven, after I have so often deserved hell? Ah, my Lord! that I had never offended Thee! Oh, if I could be reborn, I would ever love Thee! But what is done is done. Now, I can do no more than give to Thee that portion of life which remains to me. Yes, I give it all to Thee.; I consecrate it all to Thy love. Depart from my heart, ye worldly affections; give place to my God, Who desires to possess it wholly. Yes, possess me altogether, O my Redeemer, my Love, my God. From this day forward I would only think how I can please Thee. Aid me with Thy grace; this I hope for through Thy merits. More and more increase in me Thy love, and the desire to please Thee. Heaven, heaven! When will it be O Lord, that I shall see Thee face to face, and shall embrace Thee, without the fear of ever having to lose Thee. Ah, my God, hold Thy hand over me, so that I shall no more offend Thee. Help me, O my Jesus! suffer me not to lose myself, and to stand afar off from Thee.
Ad maiorem Dei gloriam!
Friday, October 30, 2026
A Bad Look for the Vatican --Bishop Marian Eleganti, OSB
A Bad Look for the Vatican - On the Blocking of Saint Peter’s to Traditional Pilgrims - by Bishop Marian Eleganti, OSB
The SPIRIT therefore called on us more than twenty-five years ago to present (once again) JESUS CHRIST to the nations as the exclusive, absolute truth, as the only door to the FATHER, as the universal and ever-valid teacher, and as the sole Redeemer of the world. Instead, we sit in circles and on chairs in order to listen. To whom? But nothing comes of it. I would say: nothing new, merely the step-by-step implementation of yesterday's demands of reform Catholicism (democracy and co-determination; control of power; laypeople in leadership positions; women in ecclesial offices; revision of sexual morality; normalization of divorce and remarriage; recognition of homosexual lifestyles and partnerships; transgenderism; preservation of creation, that is, the climate; socialist-inspired universalism: open migration and universal brotherhood; interreligious coexistence instead of mission). The elephant in the room, the correlation between abuse and homosexuality in the Catholic clergy (Dariusz Oko; Paul Sullins), continues to be ignored.
In Closing, the Joyful Part
(Original in German, from www.marian-eleganti.ch)
The Upheaval of the Breviary by Vatican II
18 years old, the French poet, dramatist and diplomat Paul Claudel was moved to conversion when he heard the Magnificat sung during Solemn Vespers on Christmas Eve 1886 at the Cathedral of Notre-Dame de Paris:
"In an instant, my heart was touched and I believed. I believed with such force, with such relief of all my being, a conviction so powerful, so certain and without any room for doubt, that ever since, all the books, all the arguments, all the hazards of my agitated life have never shaken my faith, nor to tell the truth have they even touched it." (Paul Claudel, Ma conversion in Contacts et circonstances, Gallimard, 1940, p. 11ss.)
THE DIVINE OFFICE
83. Christ Jesus, high priest of the new and eternal covenant, taking human nature, introduced into this earthly exile that hymn which is sung throughout all ages in the halls of heaven. He joins the entire community of mankind to Himself, associating it with His own singing of this canticle of divine praise.
For he continues His priestly work through the agency of His Church, which is ceaselessly engaged in praising the Lord and interceding for the salvation of the whole world. She does this, not only by celebrating the eucharist, but also in other ways, especially by praying the divine office.
84. By tradition going back to early Christian times, the divine office is devised so that the whole course of the day and night is made holy by the praises of God. Therefore, when this wonderful song of praise is rightly performed by priests and others who are deputed for this purpose by the Church's ordinance, or by the faithful praying together with the priest in the approved form, then it is truly the voice of the bride addressed to her bridegroom; It is the very prayer which Christ Himself, together with His body, addresses to the Father.
85. Hence all who render this service are not only fulfilling a duty of the Church, but also are sharing in the greatest honor of Christ's spouse, for by offering these praises to God they are standing before God's throne in the name of the Church their Mother.
86. Priests who are engaged in the sacred pastoral ministry will offer the praises of the hours with greater fervor the more vividly they realize that they must heed St. Paul's exhortation: "Pray without ceasing" (1 Thess. 5:11). For the work in which they labor will effect nothing and bring forth no fruit except by the power of the Lord who said: "Without me you can do nothing" (John 15: 5). That is why the apostles, instituting deacons, said: "We will devote ourselves to prayer and to the ministry of the word" (Acts 6:4).
81. In order that the divine office may be better and more perfectly prayed in existing circumstances, whether by priests or by other members of the Church, the sacred Council, carrying further the restoration already so happily begun by the Apostolic See, has seen fit to decree as follows concerning the office of the Roman rite.
88. Because the purpose of the office is to sanctify the day, the traditional sequence of the hours is to be restored so that once again they may be genuinely related to the time of the day when they are prayed, as far as this may be possible. Moreover, it will be necessary to take into account the modern conditions in which daily life has to be lived, especially by those who are called to labor in apostolic works.
89. Therefore, when the office is revised, these norms are to be observed:
a) By the venerable tradition of the universal Church, Lauds as morning prayer and Vespers as evening prayer are the two hinges on which the daily office turns; hence they are to be considered as the chief hours and are to be celebrated as such.
b) Compline is to be drawn up so that it will be a suitable prayer for the end of the day.
c) The hour known as Matins, although it should retain the character of nocturnal praise when celebrated in choir, shall be adapted so that it may be recited at any hour of the day; it shall be made up of fewer psalms and longer readings.
d) The hour of Prime is to be suppressed.
e) In choir the hours of Terce, Sext, and None are to be observed. But outside choir it will be lawful to select any one of these three, according to the respective time of the day.
90. The divine office, because it is the public prayer of the Church, is a source of piety, and nourishment for personal prayer. And therefore priests and all others who take part in the divine office are earnestly exhorted in the Lord to attune their minds to their voices when praying it. The better to achieve this, let them take steps to improve their understanding of the liturgy and of the bible, especially of the psalms.
In revising the Roman office, its ancient and venerable treasures are to be so adapted that all those to whom they are handed on may more extensively and easily draw profit from them.
91. So that it may really be possible in practice to observe the course of the hours proposed in Art. 89, the psalms are no longer to be distributed throughout one week, but through some longer period of time.
The work of revising the psalter, already happily begun, is to be finished as soon as possible, and is to take into account the style of Christian Latin, the liturgical use of psalms, also when sung, and the entire tradition of the Latin Church.
92. As regards the readings, the following shall be observed: a) Readings from sacred scripture shall be arranged so that the riches of God's word may be easily accessible in more abundant measure.
b) Readings excerpted from the works of the fathers, doctors, and ecclesiastical writers shall be better selected.
c) The accounts of martyrdom or the lives of the saints are to accord with the facts of history.
93. To whatever extent may seem desirable, the hymns are to be restored to their original form, and whatever smacks of mythology or ill accords with Christian piety is to be removed or changed. Also, as occasion may arise, let other selections from the treasury of hymns be incorporated.
94. That the day may be truly sanctified, and that the hours themselves may be recited with spiritual advantage, it is best that each of them be prayed at a time which most closely corresponds with its true canonical time.
95. Communities obliged to choral office are bound to celebrate the office in choir every day in addition to the conventual Mass. In particular:
a) Orders of canons, of monks and of nuns, and of other regulars bound by law or constitutions to choral office must celebrate the entire office.
b) Cathedral or collegiate chapters are bound to recite those parts of the office imposed on them by general or particular law.
c) All members of the above communities who are in major orders or who are solemnly professed, except for lay brothers, are bound to recite individually those canonical hours which they do not pray in choir.
96. Clerics not bound to office in choir, if they are in major orders, are bound to pray the entire office every day, either in common or individually, as laid down in Art. 89.
97. Appropriate instances are to be defined by the rubrics in which a liturgical service may be substituted for the divine office.
In particular cases, and for a just reason, ordinaries can dispense their subjects wholly or in part from the obligation of reciting the divine office, or may commute the obligation.
98. Members of any institute dedicated to acquiring perfection who, according to their constitutions, are to recite any parts of the divine office are thereby performing the public prayer of the Church.
They too perform the public prayer of the Church who, in virtue of their constitutions, recite any short office, provided this is drawn up after the pattern of the divine office and is duly approved.
99. Since the divine office is the voice of the Church, that is of the whole mystical body publicly praising God, those clerics who are not obliged to office in choir, especially priests who live together or who assemble for any purpose, are urged to pray at least some part of the divine office in common.
All who pray the divine office, whether in choir or in common, should fulfill the task entrusted to them as perfectly as possible: this refers not only to the internal devotion of their minds but also to their external manner of celebration.
It is, moreover, fitting that the office, both in choir and in common, be sung when possible.
100. Pastors of souls should see to it that the chief hours, especially Vespers, are celebrated in common in church on Sundays and the more solemn feasts. And the laity, too, are encouraged to recite the divine office, either with the priests, or among themselves, or even individually.
101. 1. In accordance with the centuries-old tradition of the Latin rite, the Latin language is to be retained by clerics in the divine office. But in individual cases the ordinary has the power of granting the use of a vernacular translation to those clerics for whom the use of Latin constitutes a grave obstacle to their praying the office properly. The vernacular version, however, must be one that is drawn up according to the provision of Art. 36.
2. The competent superior has the power to grant the use of the vernacular in the celebration of the divine office, even in choir, to nuns and to members of institutes dedicated to acquiring perfection, both men who are not clerics and women. The version, however, must be one that is approved.
3. Any cleric bound to the divine office fulfills his obligation if he prays the office in the vernacular together with a group of the faithful or with those mentioned in 52 above provided that the text of the translation is approved.
Critical Praise of The Tridentine Breviary, Blessed John Henry Newman
The Vatican II Overhaul of the Breviary
Wednesday, October 28, 2026
"The Faith Must Become Culture!" --Pope Leo XIV
Why do people love the Traditional Latin Mass? Because in it the faith has become culture! That is good! Here is a citation from the blog of Bishop Rob Mutsaerts who defends the Traditional Latin Mass on the grounds of legitimate cultural sensibilities which must be respected and promoted, if we are to be consistent.
"The Catholic et-et — the celebrated Catholic principle of both-and — could be a fruitful starting point here as well. Tradition and legitimate development. Unity and diversity. Fidelity to the Council and reverence for the centuries that preceded it. The new Mass and room for the transmitted Roman liturgy, within the communion of the Church.
"...[T]he Church need not forbid its past to secure its future. A Church that truly trusts in the living Tradition can afford to love its own history. A Church that receives with joy a Byzantine, Maronite, and Armenian liturgy in its midst need not feel too threatened by a Roman Mass that was so dear to it for so many centuries. The Traditional Latin Mass is, after all, no foreign intruder in the Catholic Church; it comes from her own house. And a mother Church ought not to treat her own children as strangers because they prefer to pray in the language of their grandparents."
† Rob Mutsaerts
"The relationship between faith and culture finds its primary foundation in the Incarnation: if the divine Word became flesh and came to dwell among us (cf. Jn 1:14), then faith too is an incarnate reality, interwoven with the culture in which it is immersed. It is also required to become culture, that is, to reach the person in their living environment, made up of human words, traditions, religious meaning, art and poetry, thought and science. As Saint John Paul II loved to repeat, “a faith that does not become culture is a faith not fully accepted, not entirely thought out, not faithfully lived”. (St. John Paul II, Address to participants in the Congress of the Ecclesial Movement of Cultural Commitment (MEIC), 16 January 1982.)"
Tuesday, October 27, 2026
Plinthos Response to Excommunicated Archbishop Viganò
Here is my quick response to my last post, my translation of Excommunicated Archbishop Viganò's indictment of traditional Catholics.
The excommunicated Archbishop is ironically suffering from his excessive Ultramontanism. Because he neglects to distinguish the Office of Peter from the historical holder of the Office, and, because he neglects to distinguish Papal Primacy/Supremacy from Papal Magisterial Infallibility (with all of the attendant distinctions and conditions thereof).
To accept and uphold and revel under Papal Jurisdiction is essential to Catholic identity. That is a juridical fact. All those who are officially excommunicated from the Catholic Church are not Catholic. On the other hand, all those who are baptized in the Catholic Church and are not excommunicated are Catholic. Poor Viganò, himself purportedly excommunicated, claims that all Catholics are unfaithful and excommunicated by the way they are treated and because of the errors of their leaders. There are so many errors in logic here that they are too many to enumerate. But let me try.
1. The first error is that mistreatment = de facto excommunication. False.
2. Second error is that silence = formal consent. False. The response to this error is that silence is often the normal way when a superior falls into error. An inferior does not have an inherent right to correct a superior. It is not typically the place of an inferior to correct his inferior. In rare instances an inferior might rightly correct a superior, but only when necessary, and then, only with the utmost deference. Each man should typically stay in his lane!
3. To obey an erring superior is to share in his error and therefore in the culpability of the error. False. Because of point 2 above, this is also false.
4. The faithful must disobey and reject leaders who are in error. False. They must obey in everything except sin. Witness Christ Himself. Christ obeyed sinners, religious and civil, to death, death on a Cross, and He never sinned. There are many instances of this throughout our history of Saints: e.g. Saint Pio of Pietrelcina.
5. Because of his doctrinal zeal (in his erroneous ultramontanism) Viganò sets himself as the judge of the Papal Authority. His doctrinal stance makes him confuse his obligation to obedience. He rejects the Pope's rightful jurisdiction because he disagrees with the Papal doctrinal teachings. That does not follow. The Pope is still the Supreme, Immediate, Universal authority on the earth, even when he is wrong. His jurisdiction is not infallible, but it remains Supreme and Universal, and must be obeyed, (not without just and sometimes necessary criticism) in all things but sin.
6. The fundamental problem with the Viganò position is that it condemns the entire Catholic Church. The excommunicate declares all Catholics excommunicated! Making himself the Supreme Judge in the Church, he logically dissolves the Church. He makes himself Pope, and condemns the whole world. This traditionalist error is the typical Protestant error, of not accepting the priestly/episcopal/papal, God-given hierarchical authority in the Church. The fundamental problem is that of authority and obedience.
As G.K. Chesterton said, the problem with the Protestant is not that he has no Pope, the problem is that everyman thereby makes himself Pope. If the Pope is not the Supreme earthly authority, who is? Viganò? SSPX? The Sedevacantes? The Orthodox? The Lutherans? The Anglicans? The Calvanists? The Evangelicals? The Mormons? The Jehovah's Witnesses? The Christian Scientists? The Jews? The Muslims? The secular humanists? The atheists?
Cf. Saint John Henry Cardinal Newman, Letter to the Duke of Norfolk.
P.S. There is an appeal process for excommunication, and as long as that process proceeds, the excommunication is without effect. Dear excommunicated Archbishop Viganò, you should try to work out of your excommunication. Obedience is the solution! Never consent to error, but, by all means, obey rightful authority, without sinning yourself, to death, even death on the cross!
Monday, October 26, 2026
New Scathing Viganò Indictment Must be Heard!
I, as an "excommunicated" person, address you, since that is what you consider me to be. I believe that the condition attributed to me can shed light on the one in which you yourselves actually find yourselves today.
As Ecclesia Dei communities, as Ratzinger priests and bishops, followers of Summorum Pontificum, the Mass of all time is granted to you as an exception to be justified. You are increasingly excluded from parishes; the bishop's authorization is required to celebrate what our fathers celebrated without permission. Your institutions are subjected to visits and inspections, your seminarians are viewed with suspicion, and your rite is tolerated as long as it does not disturb.
What is this, if not excommunication without trial, or worse still, the Roman authorities' desire to subjugate your conscience? An exclusion that dare name it. To avoid the sentence, you suffer it in practice. To avoid appearing "outside the Church," you live on its margins, with contortions and inconsistencies that are now plain for all to see. You dare to say there is no state of necessity, you harshly criticize the Society of Saint Pius X, you consider me a pariah... It follows that your silence does not protect you from punishment: it only takes away your right to call it unjust.
It must be acknowledged, for the sake of truth, that Leo and the modernist-synodalist elite occupying the Vatican are acting consistently. Leo firmly believes in the Second Vatican Council and is an enthusiastic promoter of its synodal version: he cannot consistently uphold the Rite of all time, which is its living denial. Summorum Pontificum has always been a chimera: the dismemberment of the one venerable Rite into two antithetical forms, a permission that depends on who grants it and is withdrawn when it is no longer useful. You cannot therefore be criticized for your trust, but for the pretense of wanting to base what is yours by divine right on the coexistence of two irreconcilable rites and on an indult that declares you barely tolerated.
Nor does it help you to appeal to religious freedom or freedom of worship, or to synodal inclusiveness, to secure a seat in the Pantheon: those who demand, on a par with everyone else, the right to practice their own religion have already admitted that the Apostolic Mass is one religious experience among others, and the Truth is one opinion among opinions. These false freedoms do not protect Tradition: they are the instrument by which Truth—the only Religion—is excluded not only from public life, but even from the Sacred Precinct.
It is not enough to reject the Council for what contradicts the Magisterium, as you are wont to repeat. Vatican II was a revolutionary event and is a permanent revolution: it must be repudiated as such, not amended with a list of corrections, because no one can remedy with a benevolent exegesis what began as a deliberate rupture.
To Cardinal Burke and Bishop Schneider, I dare say that their authority is now all superficial: they are a caricature of themselves, with their precious miters and capes, their defense of the Council and their concelebrations.
Rome is not merely silent; it does not simply "tolerate" you by confining you to increasingly cramped Indian reservations: it wants to re-educate you, and it tells you so, demanding that you—who enjoy a significant following in conservative circles—become "His Majesty's opposition," acting as gatekeepers—as they say today—and thus containing the hemorrhage of Catholics increasingly disoriented by your acquiescence to the Vatican's most scandalous blunders. And it is now evident that a controlled opposition, far from achieving any success for the cause of Roman Catholicism, is instead complicit in the destruction of the Church.
Here then is Cardinal Burke's reassuring statement: "Certainly the current situation does not constitute a state of necessity." But if a state of necessity does not exist today, after what umpteenth scandal and what unheard-of heresy will you find the courage to rise up? How many more toads are you willing to force into the mouths of those who look to you as a moral and doctrinal point of reference? After Amoris Laetitia, Pachamama, the Abu Dhabi Declaration, Traditionis Custodes, Fiducia Supplicans, Mater Populi Fidelis... and after being prevented from professing your Faith at the tomb of the Prince of the Apostles?
As I wrote in The Capital Schism: "As long as a part of Catholics (the so-called conservatives) persists in refusing to recognize the bipolarism of the 'conciliar and synodal papacy,' they will find themselves in the terrible situation of giving deliberate assent to error; in the terrible position of those who, with that complacency in servile obedience, create the premises for the 'desertio,' the abandonment of God, the withdrawal of Grace. It is precisely that recognition of error that institutionalizes it, that makes it irreversible, that disarms all resistance and that, ultimately, criminalizes those who heroically resist."
With your polite consent and by remaining silent so as not to lose what has been granted to you, you in fact lend yourselves to the operation of deception (2 Thess 2:11).
I bless you and pray for all of you.
In Christo Rege,
✠ Carlo Maria Viganò, Archbishop
Viterbo, October 24, 2026
St. Raphaëlis Archangelli
Sunday, October 25, 2026
"We Need a New Liturgical Consciousness" --Ratzinger
"We need a new liturgical consciousness, to be rid of [the] spirit of arbitrary fabrication... For fostering a true consciousness in liturgical matters, it is...important that the proscription against the form of liturgy in valid use up to 1970 should be lifted. Anyone who nowadays advocates the continuing existence of this liturgy or takes part in it is treated like a leper; all tolerance ends here. There has never been anything like this in history; in doing this we are despising and proscribing the Church's whole past. How can one trust her present if things are that way? I must say, quite openly, that I don't understand why so many of my episcopal brethren have to a great extent submitted to this rule of intolerance, which for no apparent reason is opposed to making the necessary inner reconciliation within the Church."
Joseph Ratzinger, God and the World: A Conversation with Peter Seewald, San Francisco: Ignatius, 2002, 415-416.
Traditionalists are Treated Like Lepers --Ratzinger
Cf. Sacrosanctum Concilium - Constitution on the Sacred Liturgy
Excerpts from Sacrosanctum Concilium (1963) -- Constitution on the Sacred Liturgy - Second Vatican Council
Promulgated by His Holiness Pope Paul VI On December 4, 1963
CHAPTER VI - Sacred Music
112. The musical tradition of the universal Church is a treasure of inestimable value, greater even than that of any other art. The main reason for this pre-eminence is that, as sacred song united to the words, it forms a necessary or integral part of the solemn Liturgy
Therefore sacred music is to be considered the more holy in proportion as it is more closely connected with the liturgical action, whether it adds delight to prayer, fosters unity of minds, or confers greater solemnity upon the sacred rites.
…[T]he purpose of sacred music…is the glory of God and the sanctification of the faithful…
114. The treasure of sacred music is to be preserved and fostered with great care. Choirs must be diligently promoted, especially in cathedral churches; but bishops and other pastors of souls must be at pains to ensure that, whenever the sacred action is to be celebrated with song, the whole body of the faithful may be able to contribute that active participation which is rightly theirs...
116. The Church acknowledges Gregorian chant as specially suited to the Roman Liturgy: therefore, other things being equal, it should be given pride of place in liturgical services.
But other kinds of sacred music, especially polyphony, are by no means excluded from liturgical celebrations, so long as they accord with the spirit of the liturgical action…
120. In the Latin Church the pipe organ is to be held in high esteem, for it is the traditional musical instrument which adds a wonderful splendor to the Church's ceremonies and powerfully lifts up man's mind to God and to higher things.
But other instruments also may be admitted for use in divine worship, with the knowledge and consent of the competent territorial authority…This may be done, however, only on condition that the instruments are suitable, or can be made suitable, for sacred use, accord with the dignity of the temple, and truly contribute to the edification of the faithful.
121. Composers, filled with the Christian spirit, should feel that their vocation is to cultivate sacred music and increase its store of treasures. Let them produce compositions which have the qualities proper to genuine sacred music…The texts intended to be sung must always be in conformity with Catholic doctrine; indeed they should be drawn chiefly from Holy Scripture and from liturgical sources.
Saturday, October 24, 2026
Bishop Schneider on the Summorum Pontificum Pilgrimage in Rome, Etc.
The TLM Mass was canonized by Pope Pius V as the most sure form in doctrine, in piety and in liturgy.
Not allowed in the house of the father they go to the house of the mother to complain and find solace and shelter in the one household of the faith.
Pope Francis is also in Mary Major! for his soul!
The traditional Latin Mass is the mass of the saints, of the ages!
Below is the Vigil with the Youth of France in Paris with Pope Leo XIV, a great display of traditional Catholicism. 50:00 to 109:00 minute.
By their fruits you shall know them!
Wednesday, October 21, 2026
On Excise Taxes: Inordinately Burdening the Poor!
Excise taxes are inherently regressive, meaning lower-income households spend a larger share of their income on them than wealthier households. Because low-income families consume a greater percentage of their earnings on everyday and taxed goods (such as tobacco, fuel, utilities and tolls on roads), the financial burden hits them disproportionately.
Here are two excise taxes on necessary items, a tax which inordinately affects the poor. These taxes are a much greater proportion of a poor man's money than that of a middle-class or rich man. The rich man is not affected in the least, and the middle-class man only minimally. For the poor man, it is a significant percentage of his meagre means.
Another consideration is the use of wine at Mass. To tax wine is to inordinately tax Catholic churches which use wine in divine worship. It is a tax which punishes Catholic worship, taxing a product bought by the donations of the faithful.
I'm just sayin!
N.B. Plinthos said it, and it needs to be noted! For starters, these hidden taxes should be clearly spelled out for the consumer at the moment of purchase! That disclosure should be required! Every man has a right to know who is taking his money, how and when!
Below is the breakdown State by State for liquor (beer and wine are different but similar rates, reflecting relative alcohol content) and gas.
State | ||
|---|---|---|
1 | New Hampshire | $0.00 |
1 | Wyoming | $0.00 |
3 | Missouri | $0.53 |
4 | Colorado | $0.60 |
5 | Texas | $0.63 |
6 | Kansas | $0.66 |
7 | Indiana | $0.71 |
8 | Arizona | $0.79 |
9 | Louisiana | $0.80 |
10 | Wisconsin | $0.86 |
11 | California | $0.87 |
12 | Nevada | $0.95 |
13 | Nebraska | $0.99 |
14 | Georgia | $1.00 |
15 | Massachusetts | $1.07 |
16 | Tennessee | $1.18 |
17 | Delaware | $1.19 |
18 | North Dakota | $1.30 |
18 | South Dakota | $1.30 |
20 | Rhode Island | $1.43 |
20 | South Carolina | $1.43 |
22 | Maryland | $1.44 |
23 | New Jersey | $1.45 |
24 | Oklahoma | $1.47 |
25 | Connecticut | $1.57 |
26 | Hawaii | $1.58 |
27 | New Mexico | $1.60 |
28 | New York | $1.70 |
29 | Florida | $1.72 |
30 | Pennsylvania | $1.98 |
31 | Illinois | $2.26 |
32 | Minnesota | $2.31 |
33 | West Virginia | $2.37 |
34 | Vermont | $2.39 |
35 | Mississippi | $2.48 |
36 | Kentucky | $2.53 |
37 | Arkansas | $2.58 |
38 | Montana | $2.79 |
39 | Maine | $3.15 |
40 | Ohio | $3.26 |
41 | Alaska | $3.38 |
42 | Idaho | $3.42 |
43 | Michigan | $3.86 |
44 | Iowa | $4.00 |
45 | Utah | $4.25 |
46 | North Carolina | $4.82 |
47 | Alabama | $6.04 |
48 | Virginia | $6.20 |
49 | Oregon | $6.27 |
50 | Washington | $9.69 |
State Tax | ||
|---|---|---|
1 | Alaska | 8.95¢ |
2 | Hawaii | 18.50¢ |
3 | New Mexico | 18.88¢ |
4 | Arizona | 19.00¢ |
5 | Oklahoma | 20.00¢ |
6 | Texas | 20.00¢ |
7 | Louisiana | 20.93¢ |
8 | Delaware | 23.00¢ |
9 | North Dakota | 23.03¢ |
10 | New Hampshire | 23.75¢ |
11 | Wyoming | 24.00¢ |
12 | New York | 24.18¢ |
13 | Mississippi | 24.40¢ |
14 | Nevada | 24.81¢ |
15 | Arkansas | 25.00¢ |
16 | Connecticut | 25.00¢ |
17 | Kansas | 25.03¢ |
18 | Kentucky | 26.40¢ |
19 | Tennessee | 27.40¢ |
20 | Massachusetts | 27.56¢ |
21 | South Carolina | 28.75¢ |
22 | Missouri | 29.99¢ |
23 | Iowa | 30.00¢ |
24 | South Dakota | 30.00¢ |
25 | Colorado | 30.18¢ |
26 | Alabama | 31.00¢ |
27 | Maine | 31.45¢ |
28 | Utah | 32.55¢ |
29 | Minnesota | 32.70¢ |
30 | Nebraska | 32.70¢ |
31 | Wisconsin | 32.90¢ |
32 | Idaho | 33.00¢ |
33 | Montana | 33.75¢ |
34 | Georgia | 34.05¢ |
35 | Vermont | 34.88¢ |
36 | West Virginia | 35.70¢ |
37 | Ohio | 38.50¢ |
38 | Oregon | 40.00¢ |
39 | Florida | 40.10¢ |
40 | Rhode Island | 41.12¢ |
41 | North Carolina | 41.25¢ |
42 | Virginia | 42.40¢ |
43 | Maryland | 46.81¢ |
44 | New Jersey | 49.15¢ |
45 | Michigan | 53.40¢ |
46 | Pennsylvania | 58.70¢ |
47 | Washington | 60.17¢ |
48 | Indiana | 63.10¢ |
49 | Illinois | 70.40¢ |
50 | California | 73.64¢ |
Tuesday, October 20, 2026
Saturday, October 10, 2026
Will the Sleeping Lion Ever Awaken?
Fiducia Supplicans and Amoris Laetitia still need to be overturned to eliminate the present scandal to the Church faithful and to the world, and to stop the countless sacrileges which are tacitly permitted thereby, by the Holy See.
The world is wrongly led to believe by these erroneous Vatican instructions, which still stand, that homosexual activity is OK and that receiving communion in the state of mortal sin is OK too. And there are countless parishes and numerous bishops who are promoting those sacrileges with the resultant scandal to all.
And, of course, Tucho Fernandez, the author of those errors, has to go,...yesterday!
Since faggotry is thus condoned by the Church, it is no wonder that the TLM is trashed by the same error promoting leadership! Lex credendi, lex orandi! Ambiguous teaching begets ambiguous worship!
When will Pope Leo finally wake up, alas!
__
This post was precipitated by the remarks at a TLM retreat where Plinthos gave the key address, of a prominent neo-con New Jersey priest presenter who claimed that Fiducia Supplicans is no problem! In his Q&A response to a Nigerian layman who asked the question about the harm to the faith due to the institutionized scandal of that Vatican decree, he claimed, to the chagrin of his TLM audience, that it was a lex desuata: that no couples are actually approaching parishes for those sacrilegious blessings and that, indeed, no clerics are giving them! I quickly responded that I could readily name half a dozen parishes in the Archdiocese of Newark notoriously offering every manner of blessing and encouragement to active sodomite "couples," with not so much as a hint of condemnation of the sin and scandal thereof. Those couples might even find a bishop or two in Newark to "bless" their sodomy. The Newark bishop who was made the new ordinary of Metuchen himself, a Newark priest, is notoriously the founder of one such "ministry" in a parish where he was pastor in the Archdiocese of Newark. Fiducia Supplicans is a terrible scandal to all! The scandalous McCarrick legacy continues in the Archdiocese of Newark, to the dismay of all faithful Catholics! The priests who aren't fags have to act like fags or at least not publicly condemn faggotry. They have to tacitly accept it! That's the Newark Archdiocese status quo! Exactly McCarrick! That faggotry, sanctioned by Fiducia Supplicans, is a heinous crime which wails to heaven for vengeance! And the reigning Pontiff is apparently oblivious to the calamitous cry!
Scandal is the Sin of Leading Others to Sin
Friday, October 9, 2026
Saint John Henry Newman: Honored by the Church
Saint John Henry Newman, who's feast day is today, the day of his 1845 conversion to the Catholic faith, is honored by the Church in perpetuity, and eternally!
Created Cardinal by Pope Leo XIII 12 May, 1879
Beatified by Pope Benedict XVI 19 September, 2010
Canonized by Pope Francis 13 October 2019
Declared Doctor of the Church by Pope Leo XIV 1 November 2025
Here is a confessor of the Catholic faith, priest, celibate priest, who gave testimony to the Catholicity of the Catholic Faith in the universal truth of Her dogmas and the Catholicity (universality) of that same dogmatic Catholic religion throughout history.
Newman, ever the unifier! brings the last three Roman Pontiffs together in their homage of him, our newest Doctor of the Church. Co-Patron (with Saint Thomas Aquinas) of Catholic Education!










