Of course, both Bishop Lugones and sociologist Seman may have a point, but reducing the phenomenon to purely circumstantial issues—Francis's absence or the alleged cruelty of Milei's liberal government—is astonishingly simplistic. I propose another explanation, which may have its limitations, but attempts to delve deeper than the mere social phenomenon. Certainly, a percentage of those who attended did so because they are Catholic and, as Catholics, wanted to see and be near the successor of the Apostle Peter and be confirmed by him in the faith. It was a way, and even a necessity in many cases, to express their faith and commitment to it. This fact, which Bishop Lugones and many of his colleagues omit because they are blind to these realities, cannot be ignored, but it certainly wasn't the case for the majority. The majority attended for another reason, and it wasn't to feel pity, at least not for a while. I believe, and this is my hypothesis, that they were searching for the pontiff , and I mean that in the etymological sense of the term as understood by tradition: they were searching for the bridge that connects them to the supernatural . And this need for the bridge , and consequently for the pontiff , runs throughout the history of humanity; it is anchored in the deepest recesses of the human heart, like a mysterious secret hidden in our nature, which we could define as the longing for what we were in our first parents, and which we lost with their expulsion from Paradise.
Varro, in De lingua latina (V, 83), derives pontifex from pons and facere : the pontiffs would be “those who build bridges,” because the Pons Sublicius over the Tiber, the sacred bridge of Rome, which could not have a single iron nail, was due to them. Christian tradition understood that if the pontiff builds bridges, the bridge par excellence is the one that unites the shore of men with the shore of God . And this need for a bridge implies something that modern man prefers to forget: that there is an abyss.
Rudolf Otto described it better than anyone in The Holy . Before the numinous, man experiences a twofold movement. On the one hand, there is the mysterium tremendum , the awe before a majesty that infinitely surpasses him, and what Otto calls the "creature feeling," whose formula he takes from Abraham: "I am but dust and ashes" (Gen 18:27). On the other hand, there is the fascinans, an irresistible attraction to that which terrifies him. Man cannot approach the holy, nor can he cease to seek it. From this tension arises the figure of the mediator, someone who can stand before the tremendous without being consumed, and who returns to humanity bringing something from the other side . I would venture to say that what was seen in the streets of Buenos Aires was the fascinans in its purest form, a multitude drawn by something they could not name and which could hardly be reduced to mere sympathy for a friar from Chicago with a Peruvian passport.
Rudolf Otto described it better than anyone in The Holy . Before the numinous, man experiences a twofold movement. On the one hand, there is the mysterium tremendum , the awe before a majesty that infinitely surpasses him, and what Otto calls the "creature feeling," whose formula he takes from Abraham: "I am but dust and ashes" (Gen 18:27). On the other hand, there is the fascinans, an irresistible attraction to that which terrifies him. Man cannot approach the holy, nor can he cease to seek it. From this tension arises the figure of the mediator, someone who can stand before the tremendous without being consumed, and who returns to humanity bringing something from the other side . I would venture to say that what was seen in the streets of Buenos Aires was the fascinans in its purest form, a multitude drawn by something they could not name and which could hardly be reduced to mere sympathy for a friar from Chicago with a Peruvian passport.
Mircea Eliade took it a step further, and it's the one that best suits my hypothesis. In The Sacred and the Profane, he showed that homo religiosus needs a center of the world, an axis mundi through which heaven, earth, and the underworld communicate: the cosmic mountain, the tree, Jacob's ladder, the pillar. But in Myths, Dreams, and Mysteries, there's a chapter with a very suggestive title: “The Nostalgia for Paradise in Primitive Traditions.” Eliade found the same myth in peoples with no contact with one another. In illo tempore, heaven and earth were united by a tree, a vine, a mountain, or a bridge, and people ascended and descended freely and spoke with the gods. Due to a primordial lack, that communication was broken. Since then, only a few—the shaman, the priest, the sacred king—can travel the path again, and they do so in the name of all . It is a reminder of Genesis: a garden where God walked in the cool of the day, an expulsion, and cherubim with flaming swords guarding the way to the tree of life (Gen 3:24). The bridge cut off.
Here the king appears, a topic on which I recently heard a magnificent lecture by Sebastián Porrini and Diego Ortega in Córdoba. In almost all traditional cultures, the king is not primarily an administrator but a mediator, the one who maintains the order of the cosmos and the city because he is linked to the divine. The Romans knew this so well that, when they expelled the kings, they did not dare to suppress their sacred functions. They created a rex sacrorum so that the gods would not notice the absence. It was Numa, the pious king, who, according to Livy, instituted the pontiffs, and Augustus, who understood symbols, assumed the title of Pontifex Maximus in 12 BC. From then on, all the emperors bore it, until Gratian rejected it at the end of the 4th century, and the title ended up, by one of those ironies of Providence, with the bishops of Rome . Scripture had foreshadowed this figure with Melchizedek, king of Salem and priest of the Most High, who came to meet Abraham with bread and wine (Gen 14:18), without genealogy, seemingly from nowhere. The Christian Middle Ages thrived on this intuition . The Frankish bishops gathered in Frankfurt in 794 called Charlemagne rex et sacerdos (king and priest) , and in the Palatine Academy, Alcuin called him David. The royal anointing made the king something more than a layman. Marc Bloch dedicated an entire book, The Royal Touch , to the belief that the king of France and the king of England cured scrofula with a mere touch. The Church, it is true, always maintained the Gelasian distinction between the two powers and never confused the king with the priest. But this very distinction implies that both refer to a single being who embodies both.
Tolkien understood this thoroughly. When Aragorn enters Minas Tirith after the battle, he is recognized not by his sword but by his hands: old Ioreth recalls the ancient saying that the king's hands are the hands of a healer. What reveals him as the legitimate king is that he heals Faramir, Éowyn, and Merry with the athelas, like a magic-working king from Marc Bloch. And at the heart of his lineage lies Númenor, where the king ascended three times a year to the summit of Meneltarma, the "Pillar of Heaven," to offer prayer, praise, and thanksgiving to Eru. It was the sole cult of that people, and the king presided over it. The king was high priest. The fall of Númenor begins precisely when the kings abandon Meneltarma and raise a temple to Melkor. Tolkien even left a gesture of that nostalgia: Faramir and his men, before eating, stand in silence gazing westward, toward the Númenor that once was, toward the land of the elves, and toward what lies beyond. It is the nostalgia for what we were, transformed into a ritual.
All these bridges, however, are provisional. The Letter to the Hebrews states this with a precision that the Vulgate preserves in its most beautiful form: “ Therefore, I have a great high priest, who has penetrated the heavens, Jesus, the Son of God” (Heb 4:14). Christ is the great high priest, and he is so “in the order of Melchizedek” (Ps 110:4; Heb 7), that is, king and priest at the same time, as no king on earth could be. Christ himself presents himself as the fulfillment of Eliade’s axis mundi when he tells Nathanael that he will see heaven opened and the angels ascending and descending on the Son of Man (Jn 1:51). It is Jacob’s ladder, which is no longer resting on a desert rock but on human flesh. Saint Augustine specifies that he is a mediator as a man ( Conf. X, 43), and Saint Thomas repeats it (III, q. 26, a. 2): only he who is both God and man can touch both shores .
And then the circle closes. Pascal said that the miseries of man are the miseries of a great lord, "the miseries of a dispossessed king." Adam was placed in the garden to cultivate and guard it (Genesis 2:15), with the same verbs that the Pentateuch would later use for the service of the Levites in the sanctuary. He was king of creation and priest of a temple without walls, the first pontiff. We lost the bridge when we lost Paradise, and since then we have searched for it in shamans, in sacred kings, in emperors, groping in the dark, like the Athenians who worshipped the unknown god . Modern man believes he has been cured of this longing, but it only takes a man dressed in white to walk down Avenida del Libertador for millions to take to the streets. That man is not the bridge: he is its vicar, the visible sign of a bridge that another built.
And then the circle closes. Pascal said that the miseries of man are the miseries of a great lord, "the miseries of a dispossessed king." Adam was placed in the garden to cultivate and guard it (Genesis 2:15), with the same verbs that the Pentateuch would later use for the service of the Levites in the sanctuary. He was king of creation and priest of a temple without walls, the first pontiff. We lost the bridge when we lost Paradise, and since then we have searched for it in shamans, in sacred kings, in emperors, groping in the dark, like the Athenians who worshipped the unknown god . Modern man believes he has been cured of this longing, but it only takes a man dressed in white to walk down Avenida del Libertador for millions to take to the streets. That man is not the bridge: he is its vicar, the visible sign of a bridge that another built.
I believe, then, that deep down, this was the reason why we saw seven million Argentinians go out to see the Pope, and many more watch him on their televisions, and weep. How else can we explain the emotion felt by journalists like Esteban Trebucq, Jonathan Viale, and Diego Sehinkman? The longing for what has been lost and the need for the Pope to restore it to us is not exclusive to Catholics.
The most unsettling question, however, is what those crowds found when they reached the riverbank in Palermo, Córdoba, or Luján: Were they shown the Bridge, or did our bishops only offer them, and will continue to offer them, a pleasant view of this side of the river?
The most unsettling question, however, is what those crowds found when they reached the riverbank in Palermo, Córdoba, or Luján: Were they shown the Bridge, or did our bishops only offer them, and will continue to offer them, a pleasant view of this side of the river?
...Of course, the Church in Argentina, structured in its hierarchy, has no chance of capitalizing on the momentum generated by the Pope's visit, and it doesn't for the reasons we've tirelessly repeated on this blog: our pastors, with very few exceptions, are empty vessels devoid of supernatural and Catholic meaning; they are merely mediocre agents oriented toward social change and political activism. On Thursday, barely after the papal visit ended, La Nación published an extensive interview with Bishop Jorge Lugones, SJ, and there you can see what the bishops will do: a social interpretation of the Pope's eminently supernatural and Christian message. And, if necessary, they will distort his words. The Jesuit bishop of Lomas de Zamora had no qualms whatsoever about saying that Pope Leo came to speak of "synodality," when the Pope, in none of his speeches in Argentina and Uruguay, even uttered that word or made any reference to the "synodal path." In other words, the bishops will be responsible for ruining much of the positive aspects of Leo XIV's trip.
Source: El Wanderer
