To elaborate on the Magisterium of the Catholic Church is our mission on Plinthos (Gk. "brick"); and to do so anonymously, so that, like any brick in the wall, we might do our little part in the strength of the structure of humanity almost unnoticed.
The Story (Google auto-translate from the original Spanish)
In recent months, a hypothesis has been frequently mentioned: Leo XIV is, or would be, Francis's Bonaparte. In other words, his mission would be to Bonapartize the reforms introduced by the Argentinian pontiff . This is likely to be the case; it may be entirely, or only partially. In any case, I believe it is still too early to determine. But the mere possibility warrants further consideration.
First, let's clarify the term. I'm not referring here to Bonapartism as Karl Marx understood it, but as liberal historians have understood it. They see Napoleon as the man who consolidated and disseminated the gains of the Revolution by neutralizing its violence. They argue that the Coup of 18 Brumaire was not a betrayal of the Revolution but its stabilization: Napoleon supposedly took the revolutionary principles and ideals of 1789 and institutionalized them permanently, while bringing the cycle of violence to a close (the Reign of Terror, the internal civil war, the instability of the Directory). In other words, with Bonaparte, "the Revolution ends" precisely because it is institutionalized and exported without the need for a guillotine.
Let's apply this hermeneutic to the case at hand: after the brutality of Francis's pontificate, with its arbitrary actions, rudeness, and various heresies, Leo would play the role of Napoleon: he would stabilize all those measures with a red mozzetta and good manners. This is, as I said, a hypothesis that we may finally be able to verify, to our horror, in a few years. We cannot know for sure now. But following the master Marcus Tullius Cicero, who asserts that "history is the teacher of life," let's see how history has behaved in similar cases.
Napoleon and Bonapartism
Napoleon Bonaparte exported revolutionary ideals with a gentle touch—beyond the wars. All of Europe and the new American nations that emerged during those years adopted the ideals proclaimed in the French Revolution, imposed in France through the Reign of Terror, and disseminated throughout Europe under Napoleon's aura of civilization.
It is true that the Congress of Vienna (September 1814–June 1815) was a deliberate and largely successful halt to this expansion, but structurally it was only temporary. This was because it could not dismantle Napoleon's legal and administrative framework. Furthermore, although it was able to suppress symptoms, it could not suppress causes, since constitutional liberalism and nationalism, the underlying forces, continued to operate in lodges, the underground press, universities, and secret societies throughout the Restoration. In short, in 1848, the "Springtime of the Peoples" confirmed that the reactionary order of 1815 could no longer contain the liberal and national forces it sought to stifle. If "Bonapartism" was the administrative dissemination of revolutionary principles without the Terror, the Viennese Restoration was the attempt—partially successful, but not definitive—to politically neutralize that dissemination without being able to undo its already established legal effects . If we outline what happened in those slightly more than fifty years (from 1789 to 1848), we have a revolutionary explosion imposed by terror; an expansion and stabilization with good manners; a reaction that manages to partially return to the Old Regime and a final triumph of the revolutionary ideals.
Bonapartism in the Church
Let us return to the hermeneutical exercise: Did a similar process occur in the Church? It would be too easy to think that it all began with Vatican II, but that was not the case; it began much earlier. Let us recall the figure of Cardinal Ercole Consalvi (1757-1824), Secretary of State to Pius VII. It was he who, accepting the revolutionary government of France and betraying the priests and bishops who had remained faithful to the Holy See and to traditional principles, “made a deal” with Napoleon; that is, he made a pact with the revolutionary ideals. With the Concordat of 1801 signed with Napoleon, Consalvi managed to wrest official recognition of Catholicism from the post-revolutionary French regime, even forcing the mass resignation of the entire previous French episcopate (both constitutional and non-constitutional) in order to reorganize the Church in France from scratch under papal authority, but according to the dictates of the new Emperor. This is where Vatican realpolitik is born : pure pragmatism when dealing with governments. At the commemorative congress for Consalvi held in the Vatican Museums in January 2024, Cardinal Parolin himself defined this policy as an approach that “defends and promotes the demands of the Gospel and knows how to adapt intelligently to the times,” providing answers “without romanticism” but through “continuous, discreet, and laborious work .” He further clarified: ecclesiastical realpolitik seeks “all possible solutions for the survival of local Catholicisms and, if necessary, for their development”—that is, contingent responses to contingent problems , without doctrinal preconceptions that would prevent negotiation with the current government, whatever its political leanings. Ultimately, this amounts to the practical acceptance of liberalism's triumph. Without declaring war against it, negotiations take place, seeking to obtain as many advantages as possible, even at the cost of abandoning certain principles. This is the policy applied to the countries of the communist bloc during the pontificate of Paul VI—we need only recall the suffering endured by Cardinals Mindszenty in Hungary, Slipij in Ukraine, and Stepinac in Croatia. And it is the policy currently being implemented in China : an arrangement with the communist regime, the practical acceptance of its principles in exchange for potential benefits for the Church and, of course, the betrayal of the Catholics who remained faithful.
Consalvism also had its Congress of Vienna: it was checked by two reactionary papacies, that of Gregory XVI (1831-1846) and that of Pius IX (1846-1878), a pope who turned out to be a coot, since, despite being a staunch liberal, he switched sides a couple of years after his election. With Leo XIII (1878-1903) things changed again, as foreign policy was handled by Cardinal Mariano Rampolla del Tindaro, a Consalvist. One need only recall the sad episode of the Ralliement , which responded to the dilemma: pragmatically accommodate the regime that emerged from the Revolution to preserve what was essential, or reject it outright as illegitimate? By 1890, France had been under the Third Republic for two decades, and the majority of French Catholics remained Legitimists or Orleanists at heart, hostile to the republican regime on principle and not only because of its anticlerical policies. In this situation, Leo XIII entrusted Cardinal Charles Lavigerie, Archbishop of Algiers and Carthage, with the mission of giving a public indication of the Holy See's intentions. Lavigerie did so on November 12, 1890, in the famous "Toast of Algiers," declaring that "when the will of a people has been clearly expressed... it becomes necessary to accept the existing form of government." The impact was enormous, and Leo XIII confirmed the new direction on February 16, 1892, with the encyclical Au milieu des sollicitudes. French Catholics, the Pope stated, could and should accept the Third Republic as a legitimate form of government, without this implying acceptance of its secularist laws, which remained entirely open to challenge. The underlying, explicit political objective was to form a large conservative party uniting Catholics and moderate republicans, isolating both anticlerical radicalism and intransigent monarchism. That's how it went for the Consalvistas and the rallies .
This liberal policy suffered another setback with the election of Saint Pius X. Rampolla was removed as Secretary of State and replaced by Rafael Merry del Val. Some say he was also from the Consalvi school of thought, that is, liberal, but I'm not so sure. What is certain is that the interregnum was short-lived, because with Benedict XV, a direct disciple of Rampolla, and his Secretary, Cardinal Gasparri, Consalvi's policies were consolidated, as Gasparri would also become Secretary of State under Pius XI. Two resounding and compelling historical events confirm the stabilization of Consalvi's policies within the Church . The first of these is the agreement reached by Gasparri with the Masonic government of Mexico, which ended the Cristero War by condemning all the Catholics who had risen up and given their lives in defense of and fidelity to Catholic doctrine. The second is the Lateran Pacts, also signed by Gasparri with Mussolini, by which the Church relinquished the sovereignty it had held for 1300 years. In both cases—and there are surely several more—it was a matter of pure pragmatism and a partial renunciation of many principles.
We can say, then, that Consalvism stabilized under the pontificate of Pius XI and was consolidated under that of Pius XII. This is a topic that can be debated, but I believe it was so. Eugenio Pacelli was Gasparri's right-hand man, and his pontificate, although it evokes nostalgia in many, was an example of Bonapartism, and I am referring to the discreet and slow, but relentless, permissiveness of the liberals' rise to power. It is no coincidence that Giovanni Battista Montini always held very high positions. If Pius XII had not been the Bonaparte of Consalvism, not only in the realm of the Church's foreign policy but also in theology, the catastrophe of Vatican II would have been impossible. All the bishops who participated were chosen by one of the last two Piuses.Two similar schemes
Here we see a scheme more or less similar to the previous one: a revolutionary explosion by the historical standards of the Church; a reaction that manages to partially return to the old Catholic regime and a final triumph of the ideals of liberalism.
Let's look at what has happened in recent decades, when political liberalism definitively permeated theology and internal politics of the Church. The Second Vatican Council and its subsequent spirit were a French Revolution without the guillotine, but cruel and ruthless nonetheless, which succeeded in imposing a new regime and even a new Creed . Everything was done quickly, brutally, and without regard for the consequences during the pontificate of Paul VI. John Paul II was Napoleon, for with good manners, overwhelming leadership, and firmness on certain moral issues, he Bonapartized the spirit of the Council, or, if you prefer, allowed its Bonapartization . I wrote a post on this subject in 2012, which I refer readers to so as not to repeat myself. The pontificate of Benedict XVI attempted to act as a brake, with its timid and hesitant style, almost like a Schubert impromptu. Then came Francis; They expected a hurricane that would turn the Church upside down, but it ended up being a blizzard that only served to disrupt everything and cover it in dust, with no benefit for anyone other than their own lusts. Advertisement
Will Leo be Francisco's Napoleon?
Note 1: It is not my intention to make a moral judgment of the Vatican realpolitik inaugurated by Cardinal Consalvi. That is another discussion; here I have simply narrated the historical facts. It would be very easy to say simply that it was a capitulation of the principles upheld by the Church. The issue is much more complex.
Note 2: I have been struck by the fact that some good friends have been viciously criticizing Pope Leo XIV for mentioning in France the revolutionary motto of "Liberty, Equality, Fraternity". But as I discussed with one of them in X, such a gesture is not a novelty but the repetition of a two-hundred-year-old pattern: just as Pius VII, after the Terror, negotiated the Concordat of 1801 with Napoleon—heir of the Revolution—without thereby endorsing its ideological origin, and just as Leo XIII, in Au milieu des sollicitudes (1892), asked French Catholics for the ralliement to the Third Republic, distinguishing the form of government from the obedience due to the constituted power (Rom 13:1), Leo XIV, in the Élysée Palace, did not challenge "Liberty, Equality, Fraternity" as hostile vocabulary, but rather renamed it, affirming that its true foundation lies in the Gospel—the same patristic logic of "the plundering of the Egyptians" applied to political language.
"...[T]hough the Second Vatican Council permitted the substitution of vernacular liturgies where pastoral reasons suggested their usefulness, it commanded that the Latin be preserved. The Catholic Faith is so intimately bound to the two thousand years of Latin prayers any attempt to live the Catholic life without them will result in its attrition and ultimate apostasy--which we have witnessed in the few years of the vernacular experiment." John Senior, The Restoration of Christian Culture, (originally published in 1983), IHS Press: Norfolk, 2008, pp. 60-61.
I am a Vatican II priest who entered college seminary in 1987, and, upon the encouragement of my priest mentors, studied and loved the Second Vatican Council documents. My generation of priests is partially responsible for the new translation of the Roman Missal in English and for Summorum pontificum. We received and promoted the explicit liturgical requirements and preferences of Sacrosanctum concilium in a "hermeneutic of continuity": e.g. Latin, Gregorian Chant, Polyphony, the Organ as the preferred instrument of the Liturgy, etc. Because of the "hermeneutic of rupture" prevalent in the liturgy throughout the Roman Catholic parishes I have slowly been side-lined into almost exclusive Traditional Latin Mass ministry, simply because I love and wear the cassock and love and promote the Vatican II liturgical patrimony. I am not against the Mass of Paul VI. That Mass and its fanatical promoters are against me! But because I love and proudly promote the liturgical and cultural tradition of the Church I am typically "cancelled" or, at least, set aside, by the "tolerant" leadership of the Church at every level. When will the Church hierarchy finally embrace the liturgical norms of Vatican Council II? Even Pope Leo XIV seems totally oblivious to the specifics thereof. When will the cathedrals of the Catholic world promote Mass in Latin with Gregorian Chant and Polyphony holding pride of place? Only when that happens will we have a Vatican II Church! Ironically, the Society of Pius X is more consistent with Vatican II than most of the bishops and pastors of the Roman Catholic world.
The questions and problems relating to the Priestly Society of Saint Pius X (SSPX) have been the subject of a largely fruitless debate for over fifty years and have now culminated in the announced episcopal consecrations, which have not yet been approved by the Holy See. The discussion has been fueled by emotion—often quite literally cum ira et studio—and is frequently conducted by individuals who lack direct familiarity with the relevant documents or personal experience of the SSPX. In many cases, their knowledge is superficial and shaped by preconceived judgments. As a result, the debate often resembles a dialogue of the deaf, in which the same arguments are endlessly repeated without any meaningful progress.
Moreover, the debate largely bypasses the central issue raised by the SSPX. This failure stems from a fundamental methodological error and a lack of fact-based justification concerning the objective doctrinal and liturgical ambiguities that lie at the heart of the controversy. At its core, the conflict revolves around the question of truth.
1. Vatican II in the Context of the Other Twenty Ecumenical Councils
The first error consists in treating a pastoral council—in this case, the Second Vatican Council—as though it were entirely dogmatic, and presuming that all its statements are to be regarded as definitively proposed and binding upon all Catholics. Those who do so overlook that Paul VI himself stated: “There are those who ask what authority, what theological qualification the Council intended to give to its teachings, knowing that it avoided issuing solemn dogmatic definitions engaging the infallibility of the ecclesiastical Magisterium. The answer is known by whoever remembers the conciliar declaration of March 6, 1964, repeated on November 16, 1964: given the Council’s pastoral character, it avoided pronouncing, in an extraordinary manner, dogmas endowed with the note of infallibility.” (General Audience, January 12, 1966). This applies also to the Council’s two “dogmatic” constitutions, Dei Verbum and Lumen gentium, since the adjective “dogmatic” possesses a broader meaning and is not limited to dogmas understood as teachings endowed with infallibility.
Among the other twenty ecumenical councils, one finds numerous pastoral or disciplinary statements and documents that are no longer applicable today (e.g., the decree of the Fourth Lateran Council stating: “If a temporal lord neglects to cleanse his territory of the heretical filth, he shall be bound with the bond of excommunication”) as well as non-definitive doctrinal statements (e.g., on the matter and form of the sacrament of Holy Orders from the Council of Florence) that were later corrected by the Magisterium of the Church. One cannot absolutize every concrete historical form of Church leadership, for doing so would eliminate the necessary distinction between, on the one hand, the unchanging and enduring truths of faith (Depositum Fidei) and, on the other, the various modes by which those truths are transmitted (e.g., a pastoral statement, non-definitive doctrinal statement, or ex-cathedra definition), each of which carries a different degree of authority and binding force.
Today, however, to be in full communion with the Holy See, one must accept those affirmations and teachings of Vatican II that are pastoral and certainly non-definitive in terms of their magisterial nature. This raises an important question: Why is the unconditional acceptance of the texts of Vatican II presented as a conditio sine qua non for full communion with the Holy See, while no comparable requirement exists with respect to the pastoral, disciplinary, or non-definitive teachings of the preceding twenty Ecumenical Councils?
Among the non-definitive teachings of Vatican II there are several—particularly those concerning religious liberty, ecumenism, interreligious dialogue, and collegiality—whose formulations are ambiguous and difficult to reconcile with doctrines taught consistently by the Magisterium from the era of the Church Fathers through the period immediately preceding the Council.
There is also the question of the ritual and doctrinal deficiencies of the Novus Ordo Missae. Such concerns can no longer be dismissed out of hand, as evidenced, for example, by the testimony of Archimandrite Boniface Luykx, in his book A Wider View of Vatican II: Memories and Analysis of a Council Consultor (Angelico Press, Brooklyn, NY, 2025). The defects of the Novus Ordo Missae remain a matter of serious discussion and cannot simply be glossed over. Nevertheless, the Holy See is asking the SSPX to accept non only the validity but also the legitimacy and goodness of the liturgical reform in the Novus Ordo Missae.
2. Two modern excesses in the life of the Church: legalism and papal-centrism
The resolution of the SSPX question is hindered not only by a reluctance to confront, with intellectual honesty, the underlying doctrinal issues and to acknowledge the existence of doctrinal ambiguities requiring correction but also by an unhealthy mentality that has developed within the Church over the past several centuries: namely, the primacy of legalism or juridical positivism, together with an excessive papal-centrism that approaches a quasi-divinization of both the office and the person of the Pope.
These modern exaggerations distort and constrain the life of the Church by subordinating the primacy of the purity and clarity of the faith and liturgy to the demands of legalism and papal-centrism—a phenomenon foreign to the Fathers of the Church and to the great tradition. In this exaggerated form of papal-centrism, the Pope and his magisterium, even when not strictly dogmatic or definitive, tend to be treated as possessing an absolute and quasi-divine character. The ecclesial climate has often been shaped, at least implicitly, by assumptions that approximate such attitudes.
Most commentators on the current controversy surrounding the SSPX episcopal consecrations remain, often unwittingly, influenced by the excesses of legalism and exaggerated papal-centrism that characterize much of contemporary ecclesial life. The law that episcopal consecrations carried out without papal authorization—or contrary to the Pope’s expressed will—constitute a schismatic act, was foreign to the era of the Church Fathers. Indeed, this law only came into force in the second millennium. Canon 1387 of the 1983 Code of Canon Law, which prohibits the consecration of a bishop without a pontifical mandate, is classified among the “Offenses against the Sacraments,” rather than among the “Offenses against the Faith and Unity of the Church,” where schism is penalized (can. 1364). Were episcopal consecration without a pontifical mandate intrinsically schismatic, it would be located among offenses “against Unity of the Church.” The corresponding canon in the 1917 Code was likewise included among the “Delicts in the Administration and Reception of Orders and other Sacraments” (Title XVI), rather than among the “Delicts against the Faith and Unity of the Church” (Title XI).
3. The Extraordinary State of Crisis, and even Emergency, in the Church
Since the Second Vatican Council, the Catholic Church has been experiencing a climate of general ambiguity, vagueness, and uncertainty regarding important doctrines such as the uniqueness of Christ the Redeemer, the uniqueness of the Catholic Church, the divinely established monarchical structure of the Church (on the universal and the local level), and the sacrificial character of the Holy Mass. It is unmistakably evident that those who have held administrative power in the Holy See for the past decades, and still hold it today, demand from the SSPX as a conditio sine qua non for full communion with the Holy See the acceptance of the de facto climate of doctrinal and liturgical ambiguity and relativism, which has reached its peak with the current, extremely confusing, synodal process throughout the entire Church. Since the Council, with some of the mentioned ambiguous teachings, a process has been underway to establish, with the authority of the Roman Pontiff, a so-called “Church of Vatican II” or the “Conciliar Church.” This tendency, in our day under the new name of the “Synodal Church,” basically aims to be a relativist religion adapted to the world. Attempts to disguise this new trend toward an ambiguous, relativistic, and worldly form of the Catholic Church through a hermeneutic of continuity are dishonest and unconvincing.
4. The SSPX’s Dilemma of Conscience
The Holy See is requiring the SSPX to accept ambiguously formulated and non-definitive doctrines as a conditio sine qua non for full communion with the Holy See and for receiving canonical regularization. These include teachings concerning religious freedom, ecumenism, interreligious dialogue (including e.g., the statement of Lumen Gentium 16 that Muslims, together with Catholics, “adore the one and merciful God”), episcopal collegiality (as understood in a manner that diminishes the Church’s divinely instituted monarchical structure), and the liturgical reforms associated with the Novus Ordo Missae. The Holy See is also requiring the SSPX to formally recognize the declarations and teachings of the post-conciliar Popes that belong to the so-called authentic and daily magisterium. These include, for example, certain statements in Amoris Laetitia that seriously undermine and even contradict Divine Revelation; Pope Francis’ formal permission for divorced and remarried people to receive Holy Communion; and the Declaration on blessings for same-sex couples, Fiducia Supplicans.
If one examines with intellectual honesty the extraordinary crisis that has afflicted the Church since the Council—together with the ambiguities and the doctrinal, liturgical, and pastoral relativism that have accompanied it—then the existence and activity of the SSPX may be viewed, from a long-term perspective and in the light of the Church’s two-thousand-year history, as a work of divine providence and as a source of assistance to the Church during a crisis of unprecedented magnitude.
In reading the recent documents issued by the SSPX Superior General, Father Davide Pagliarani, particularly the Declaration of Catholic Faith and his Message to the Society and its faithful (attached below), one cannot fail to note a thoroughly Catholic spirit, imbued with a true faith in papal primacy and a filial devotion toward the person of the Supreme Pontiff.
The problem facing the SSPX is not difficult to understand. The Holy See requires that the SSPX accept, without substantial objection, certain objectively ambiguous and non-definite teachings of the Second Vatican Council, ambiguous statements of the post-conciliar papal magisterium, and objective doctrinal and ritual flaws in the Novus Ordo. Yet God has never demanded the acceptance of doctrines that are unclear or ambiguously formulated, and throughout her history the Church has always acted accordingly.
The SSPX considers it one of its essential reasons for existence to call, with parrhesia, for a return to the absolute clarity and purity of doctrine that the Church has always sought to preserve throughout the centuries. In the past, the Roman Pontiffs endured persecution, martyrdom, and even schisms rather than tolerate the slightest ambiguity in the expression of the faith. Among the most notable examples are the rejection of the ambiguous term homoiousios; the rejection of the Henotikon, which, although not formally heretical, nevertheless undermined the clarity of Christological doctrine and facilitated the spread of Monophysitism; and the rejection of the ambiguous Christological formulations of Pope Honorius I (+638). Several Popes condemned Honorius I posthumously, not for heresy, but for doctrinal ambiguity and for having aided the spread of heresy. Unity is not, in itself, the ultimate criterion of truth. Church history knows numerous situations in which tensions existed between tradition and the actual exercise of ecclesiastical authority.
The very fact that certain teachings of the Second Vatican Council, together with the liturgical reform, have given rise—and continue to give rise, both in theory and in practice—to a weakening of doctrinal clarity obliges the Pope, following the example of many of his heroic predecessors, to clarify and, where necessary, amend these teachings. This should be done with such renewed doctrinal precision and clarity that no room remains for ambiguous or erroneous interpretations. In this regard, the following principle, which has long guided the Roman Pontiffs, remains more relevant than ever: “Ambiguity can never be tolerated in a Synod (Council), whose principal glory consists above all in teaching the truth with clarity and excluding all danger of error” (Pius VI, Auctorem fidei).
The tragedy of the present situation is that the Holy See requires the SSPX to accept the existing state of doctrinal and liturgical ambiguity as a conditio sine qua non for full communion and canonical regularization. During the Monothelite controversy, when Pope Honorius I adopted an ambiguous position, the holy Patriarch Sophronius of Jerusalem sent his suffragan, Stephen, Bishop of Dor, to Rome, instructing him to go to the Apostolic See, where the foundations of orthodox doctrine are found, and not to cease praying and petitioning until those in authority examined and condemned the novel error. Bishop Stephen remained in Rome for ten years, persevering in this mission until he witnessed the condemnation of the heresy by Pope Martin I at the Lateran Council of 649. In a certain sense, the SSPX is fulfilling a similar role today, unceasingly urging the Holy See to bring an end to the situation of doctrinal and liturgical ambiguity and uncertainty. The SSPX has repeatedly declared that it has no other intention than to form the souls entrusted to its pastoral care into good Christians and true sons and daughters of the Roman Church. Ultimately, one ought to be grateful to the SSPX for this role, future Popes certainly will be.
5. The Pope’s Pastoral Solution to the SSPX Problem
The Holy See should give due consideration to the Declaration of the Catholic Faith and the Message to the Faithful issued by the Superior General of the SSPX, and should recognize these documents and acts as sufficient, and satisfying the minimum conditions, for ecclesial communion. An excommunication at the present time would open a new, unnecessary, and avoidable wound in the Mystical Body of Christ.
In light of these documents and acts of the SSPX, the Pope, with his paternal heart, could make an exception and permit episcopal consecrations through a truly generous pastoral gesture. By imposing an excommunication upon the consecrating and consecrated bishops, the Supreme Pontiff would be punishing implicitly also the faithful of the SSPX—a portion of his flock—who sincerely love and recognize him, yet who, because of what they perceive to be a genuine dilemma of conscience, see no alternative but to continue to be pastorally assisted by the SSPX, for whose existence the episcopate remains indispensable, particularly for the administration of the sacraments of Holy Orders and Confirmation.
Therefore, solely for the good of souls and the good of the Church, the SSPX is asking that the Supreme Pontiff show understanding, under the present circumstances, for its need to have bishops and permit the episcopal consecrations. Regrettably, despite what it regards as an objective dilemma of conscience, the SSPX is, for the most part, characterized as schismatic and proud.
With a spirit of magnanimity, the Supreme Pontiff, as a true father, could build a bridge to the SSPX, this portion of his flock, and permit the episcopal consecrations on an exceptional basis in order to foster a climate in which, through greater mutual trust, a solution to the doctrinal questions and the corresponding juridical arrangements may be found patiently and gradually. The synodal Church of our day should be capable of such pastoral breadth and generosity. In light of the many generous ecumenical statements and initiatives of recent decades, it should likewise demonstrate its capacity to address a serious ecclesial problem through dialogue, patience, and understanding inside the Catholic Church.
Recently, Cardinal Pietro Parolin, the Vatican Secretary of State, affirmed that, regarding the deviations of the German bishops, the Holy See does not wish divisions to escalate into punitive measures, emphasizing that problems within the Church should, whenever possible, be resolved peacefully. Why should this approach not also be applied to the SSPX, which denies no dogma, recognizes the primacy of the Pope, prays for him, and professes filial devotion to him, while preserving only what the Church believed and celebrated universally until the Council? At the same time, the German Synodal Way has advanced clear doctrinal deviations that promote de facto heresies and even blasphemous positions. Why, then, should reconciliation and patient dialogue be emphasized in one case but not in the other?
If, this year, the Pope were to pronounce an excommunication, a new anathema, upon the consecrating and consecrated bishops, it would go down in Church history as an error of excessive pastoral severity. Future generations and future Popes would come to regret it. Why should the Pope do today what future generations may lament tomorrow? Should we not learn from history? Is not the Pope, as the Supreme Pontiff, called above all to be a builder of bridges? Attachments:
While we recognize that the [fourth century] decision of Rome at that time to go over from the Greek to the Latin liturgy was unquestionably the right one, we cannot overlook the fact that this decision marked the beginning of the separation between East and West, which was to a very great extent a linguistic and liturgical problem. Language is a factor of much greater importance than we generally realise. At this hour therefore [1966] when the Church is girding herself for another stage in her journey through history, she must remember that while the translation of the liturgy into the vernacular is dictated by the circumstances of the time, it should not be made a pretext for the destruction of everything which comes to her from the past. There is a law of continuity [cf. Ratzinger's hermeneutic of continuity vs. that of rupture] which we transgress at our peril.
All this means that the liturgical reform calls for a very generous measure of tolerance within the Church [e.g. Summorum Pontificum's magnanimous breadth of liturgical freedom!], which in the given situation is only another way of saying that it calls for a great measure of Christian charity. And the fact that this charity is often so little to be found is perhaps the real crisis for the liturgical renewal in our midst. The "bearing with one another" of which Saint Paul speaks, the diffusion of charity of which we read in Saint Augustine--it is these alone that can create the setting within which the revival of Christian worship can grow in maturity and achieve its true flowering. For the real divine worship of Christianity consists in charity.
Joseph Ratzinger, "Catholicism After the Council," A lecture delivered to the Katholikentag of 1966 in Bamberg. Translated by Father Patrick Russell; The Furrow, Vol. 18, No. 1 (Jan., 1967), pp. 3-23.
Yesterday I watched Pope Leo XIV's first 22 December Christmas Address to the Roman Curia. Listening to the Holy Father's vague address, filled with unclear and too cliche and ambiguous to be helpful religious platitudes--"mission," "shepherding," and "communion,"--I found myself nostalgic for the abundantly clear and doctrinally rich mission statements of Pope Benedict XVI's Christmas Addresses to the Roman Curia, beginning with his first, in 2005, an unambigious response to the relativism of our time: a true missionary, a true shepherd and a true promoter of Catholic communion, calling out the wolves and committing to getting rid of them!
ADDRESS OF HIS HOLINESS BENEDICT XVI TO THE ROMAN CURIA OFFERING THEM HIS CHRISTMAS GREETINGS
Thursday, 22 December 2005
Your Eminences, Venerable Brothers in the Episcopate and in the Presbyterate, Dear Brothers and Sisters,
"Expergiscere, homo: quia pro te Deus factus est homo - Wake up, O man! For your sake God became man" (St Augustine, Sermo, 185). With the Christmas celebrations now at hand, I am opening my Meeting with you, dear collaborators of the Roman Curia, with St Augustine's invitation to understand the true meaning of Christ's Birth.
I address to each one my most cordial greeting and I thank you for the sentiments of devotion and affection, effectively conveyed to me by your Cardinal Dean, to whom I address my gratitude.
God became man for our sake: this is the message which, every year, from the silent grotto of Bethlehem spreads even to the most out-of-the-way corners of the earth. Christmas is a feast of light and peace, it is a day of inner wonder and joy that expands throughout the universe, because "God became man". From the humble grotto of Bethlehem, the eternal Son of God, who became a tiny Child, addresses each one of us: he calls us, invites us to be reborn in him so that, with him, we may live eternally in communion with the Most Holy Trinity.
Our hearts brimming with the joy that comes from this knowledge, let us think back to the events of the year that is coming to an end. We have behind us great events which have left a deep mark on the life of the Church. I am thinking first and foremost of the departure of our beloved Holy Father John Paul II, preceded by a long period of suffering and the gradual loss of speech. No Pope has left us such a quantity of texts as he has bequeathed to us; no previous Pope was able to visit the whole world like him and speak directly to people from all the continents.
In the end, however, his lot was a journey of suffering and silence. Unforgettable for us are the images of Palm Sunday when, holding an olive branch and marked by pain, he came to the window and imparted the Lord's Blessing as he himself was about to walk towards the Cross.
Next was the scene in his Private Chapel when, holding the Crucifix, he took part in the Way of the Cross at the Colosseum, where he had so often led the procession carrying the Cross himself.
Lastly came his silent Blessing on Easter Sunday, in which we saw the promise of the Resurrection, of eternal life, shine out through all his suffering. With his words and actions, the Holy Father gave us great things; equally important is the lesson he imparted to us from the chair of suffering and silence.
In his last book "Memory and Identity" (Weidenfeld and Nicolson, 2005), he has left us an interpretation of suffering that is not a theological or philosophical theory but a fruit that matured on his personal path of suffering which he walked, sustained by faith in the Crucified Lord. This interpretation, which he worked out in faith and which gave meaning to his suffering lived in communion with that of the Lord, spoke through his silent pain, transforming it into an important message.
Both at the beginning and once again at the end of the book mentioned, the Pope shows that he is deeply touched by the spectacle of the power of evil, which we dramatically experienced in the century that has just ended. He says in his text: "The evil... was not a small-scale evil.... It was an evil of gigantic proportions, an evil which availed itself of state structures in order to accomplish its wicked work, an evil built up into a system" (p. 189).
Might evil be invincible? Is it the ultimate power of history? Because of the experience of evil, for Pope Wojty³a the question of redemption became the essential and central question of his life and thought as a Christian. Is there a limit against which the power of evil shatters? "Yes, there is", the Pope replies in this book of his, as well as in his Encyclical on redemption.
The power that imposes a limit on evil is Divine Mercy. Violence, the display of evil, is opposed in history - as "the totally other" of God, God's own power - by Divine Mercy. The Lamb is stronger than the dragon, we could say together with the Book of Revelation.
At the end of the book, in a retrospective review of the attack of 13 May 1981 and on the basis of the experience of his journey with God and with the world, John Paul II further deepened this answer.
What limits the force of evil, the power, in brief, which overcomes it - this is how he says it - is God's suffering, the suffering of the Son of God on the Cross: "The suffering of the Crucified God is not just one form of suffering alongside others.... In sacrificing himself for us all, Christ gave a new meaning to suffering, opening up a new dimension, a new order: the order of love.... The passion of Christ on the Cross gave a radically new meaning to suffering, transforming it from within.... It is this suffering which burns and consumes evil with the flame of love.... All human suffering, all pain, all infirmity contains within itself a promise of salvation;... evil is present in the world partly so as to awaken our love, our self-gift in generous and disinterested service to those visited by suffering.... Christ has redeemed the world: "By his wounds we are healed' (Is 53: 5)" (p. 189, ff.).
All this is not merely learned theology, but the expression of a faith lived and matured through suffering. Of course, we must do all we can to alleviate suffering and prevent the injustice that causes the suffering of the innocent. However, we must also do the utmost to ensure that people can discover the meaning of suffering and are thus able to accept their own suffering and to unite it with the suffering of Christ.
In this way, it is merged with redemptive love and consequently becomes a force against the evil in the world.
The response across the world to the Pope's death was an overwhelming demonstration of gratitude for the fact that in his ministry he offered himself totally to God for the world; a thanksgiving for the fact that in a world full of hatred and violence he taught anew love and suffering in the service of others; he showed us, so to speak, in the flesh, the Redeemer, redemption, and gave us the certainty that indeed, evil does not have the last word in the world.
The World Youth Day has lived on as a great gift in the memory of those present. More than a million young people gathered in the City of Cologne on the Rhine River and in the neighbouring towns to listen together to the Word of God, to pray together, to receive the Sacraments of Reconciliation and the Eucharist, to sing and to celebrate together, to rejoice in life and to worship and receive the Lord in the Eucharist during the great meetings on Saturday evening and Sunday. Joy simply reigned throughout those days.
Apart from keeping order, the police had nothing to do - the Lord had gathered his family, tangibly overcoming every frontier and barrier, and in the great communion between us, he made us experience his presence.
The motto chosen for those days - "We have come to worship him!", contained two great images which encouraged the right approach from the outset. First there was the image of the pilgrimage, the image of the person who, looking beyond his own affairs and daily life, sets out in search of his essential destination, the truth, the right life, God.
This image of the person on his way towards the goal of life contained another two clear indications. First of all, there was the invitation not to see the world that surrounds us solely as raw material with which we can do something, but to try to discover in it "the Creator's handwriting", the creative reason and the love from which the world was born and of which the universe speaks to us, if we pay attention, if our inner senses awaken and acquire perception of the deepest dimensions of reality.
As a second element there is a further invitation: to listen to the historical revelation which alone can offer us the key to the interpretation of the silent mystery of creation, pointing out to us the practical way towards the true Lord of the world and of history, who conceals himself in the poverty of the stable in Bethlehem.
The other image contained in the World Youth Day motto was the person worshipping: "We have come to worship him". Before any activity, before the world can change there must be worship. Worship alone sets us truly free; worship alone gives us the criteria for our action. Precisely in a world in which guiding criteria are absent and the threat exists that each person will be a law unto himself, it is fundamentally necessary to stress worship.
For all those who were present the intense silence of that million young people remains unforgettable, a silence that united and uplifted us all when the Lord in the Blessed Sacrament was placed on the altar. Let us cherish in our hearts the images of Cologne: they are signs that continue to be valid. Without mentioning individual names, I would like on this occasion to thank everyone who made World Youth Day possible; but especially, let us together thank the Lord, for indeed, he alone could give us those days in the way in which we lived them.
The word "adoration" [worship] brings us to the second great event that I wish to talk about: the Synod of Bishops and the Year of the Eucharist. Pope John Paul II, with the Encyclical Ecclesia de Eucharistia and the Apostolic Letter Mane Nobiscum Domine, gave us the essential clues and at the same time, with his personal experience of Eucharistic faith, put the Church's teaching into practice.
Moreover, the Congregation for Divine Worship, in close connection with the Encyclical, published the Instruction Redemptionis Sacramentum as a practical guide to the correct implementation of the conciliar Constitution on the liturgy and liturgical reform. In addition to all this, was it really possible to say anything new, to develop further the whole of this teaching?
This was exactly the great experience of the Synod, during which a reflection of the riches of the Eucharistic life of the Church today and the inexhaustibility of her Eucharistic faith could be perceived in the Fathers' contributions. What the Fathers thought and expressed must be presented, in close connection with the Propositiones of the Synod, in a Post-Synodal Document.
Here, once again, I only wish to underline that point which a little while ago we already mentioned in the context of World Youth Day: adoration of the Risen Lord, present in the Eucharist with flesh and blood, with body and soul, with divinity and humanity.
It is moving for me to see how everywhere in the Church the joy of Eucharistic adoration is reawakening and being fruitful. In the period of liturgical reform, Mass and adoration outside it were often seen as in opposition to one another: it was thought that the Eucharistic Bread had not been given to us to be contemplated, but to be eaten, as a widespread objection claimed at that time.
The experience of the prayer of the Church has already shown how nonsensical this antithesis was. Augustine had formerly said: "...nemo autem illam carnem manducat, nisi prius adoraverit;... peccemus non adorando - No one should eat this flesh without first adoring it;... we should sin were we not to adore it" (cf. Enarr. in Ps 98: 9 CCL XXXIX 1385).
Indeed, we do not merely receive something in the Eucharist. It is the encounter and unification of persons; the person, however, who comes to meet us and desires to unite himself to us is the Son of God. Such unification can only be brought about by means of adoration.
Receiving the Eucharist means adoring the One whom we receive. Precisely in this way and only in this way do we become one with him. Therefore, the development of Eucharistic adoration, as it took shape during the Middle Ages, was the most consistent consequence of the Eucharistic mystery itself: only in adoration can profound and true acceptance develop. And it is precisely this personal act of encounter with the Lord that develops the social mission which is contained in the Eucharist and desires to break down barriers, not only the barriers between the Lord and us but also and above all those that separate us from one another.
The last event of this year on which I wish to reflect here is the celebration of the conclusion of the Second Vatican Council 40 years ago. This memory prompts the question: What has been the result of the Council? Was it well received? What, in the acceptance of the Council, was good and what was inadequate or mistaken? What still remains to be done? No one can deny that in vast areas of the Church the implementation of the Council has been somewhat difficult, even without wishing to apply to what occurred in these years the description that St Basil, the great Doctor of the Church, made of the Church's situation after the Council of Nicea: he compares her situation to a naval battle in the darkness of the storm, saying among other things: "The raucous shouting of those who through disagreement rise up against one another, the incomprehensible chatter, the confused din of uninterrupted clamouring, has now filled almost the whole of the Church, falsifying through excess or failure the right doctrine of the faith..." (De Spiritu Sancto, XXX, 77; PG 32, 213 A; SCh 17 ff., p. 524).
We do not want to apply precisely this dramatic description to the situation of the post-conciliar period, yet something from all that occurred is nevertheless reflected in it. The question arises: Why has the implementation of the Council, in large parts of the Church, thus far been so difficult?
Well, it all depends on the correct interpretation of the Council or - as we would say today - on its proper hermeneutics, the correct key to its interpretation and application. The problems in its implementation arose from the fact that two contrary hermeneutics came face to face and quarrelled with each other. One caused confusion, the other, silently but more and more visibly, bore and is bearing fruit.
On the one hand, there is an interpretation that I would call "a hermeneutic of discontinuity and rupture"; it has frequently availed itself of the sympathies of the mass media, and also one trend of modern theology. On the other, there is the "hermeneutic of reform", of renewal in the continuity of the one subject-Church which the Lord has given to us. She is a subject which increases in time and develops, yet always remaining the same, the one subject of the journeying People of God.
The hermeneutic of discontinuity risks ending in a split between the pre-conciliar Church and the post-conciliar Church. It asserts that the texts of the Council as such do not yet express the true spirit of the Council. It claims that they are the result of compromises in which, to reach unanimity, it was found necessary to keep and reconfirm many old things that are now pointless. However, the true spirit of the Council is not to be found in these compromises but instead in the impulses toward the new that are contained in the texts.
These innovations alone were supposed to represent the true spirit of the Council, and starting from and in conformity with them, it would be possible to move ahead. Precisely because the texts would only imperfectly reflect the true spirit of the Council and its newness, it would be necessary to go courageously beyond the texts and make room for the newness in which the Council's deepest intention would be expressed, even if it were still vague.
In a word: it would be necessary not to follow the texts of the Council but its spirit. In this way, obviously, a vast margin was left open for the question on how this spirit should subsequently be defined and room was consequently made for every whim.
The nature of a Council as such is therefore basically misunderstood. In this way, it is considered as a sort of constituent that eliminates an old constitution and creates a new one. However, the Constituent Assembly needs a mandator and then confirmation by the mandator, in other words, the people the constitution must serve. The Fathers had no such mandate and no one had ever given them one; nor could anyone have given them one because the essential constitution of the Church comes from the Lord and was given to us so that we might attain eternal life and, starting from this perspective, be able to illuminate life in time and time itself.
Through the Sacrament they have received, Bishops are stewards of the Lord's gift. They are "stewards of the mysteries of God" (I Cor 4: 1); as such, they must be found to be "faithful" and "wise" (cf. Lk 12: 41-48). This requires them to administer the Lord's gift in the right way, so that it is not left concealed in some hiding place but bears fruit, and the Lord may end by saying to the administrator: "Since you were dependable in a small matter I will put you in charge of larger affairs" (cf. Mt 25: 14-30; Lk 19: 11-27).
These Gospel parables express the dynamic of fidelity required in the Lord's service; and through them it becomes clear that, as in a Council, the dynamic and fidelity must converge.
The hermeneutic of discontinuity is countered by the hermeneutic of reform, as it was presented first by Pope John XXIII in his Speech inaugurating the Council on 11 October 1962 and later by Pope Paul VI in his Discourse for the Council's conclusion on 7 December 1965.
Here I shall cite only John XXIII's well-known words, which unequivocally express this hermeneutic when he says that the Council wishes "to transmit the doctrine, pure and integral, without any attenuation or distortion". And he continues: "Our duty is not only to guard this precious treasure, as if we were concerned only with antiquity, but to dedicate ourselves with an earnest will and without fear to that work which our era demands of us...". It is necessary that "adherence to all the teaching of the Church in its entirety and preciseness..." be presented in "faithful and perfect conformity to the authentic doctrine, which, however, should be studied and expounded through the methods of research and through the literary forms of modern thought. The substance of the ancient doctrine of the deposit of faith is one thing, and the way in which it is presented is another...", retaining the same meaning and message (The Documents of Vatican II, Walter M. Abbott, S.J., p. 715).
It is clear that this commitment to expressing a specific truth in a new way demands new thinking on this truth and a new and vital relationship with it; it is also clear that new words can only develop if they come from an informed understanding of the truth expressed, and on the other hand, that a reflection on faith also requires that this faith be lived. In this regard, the programme that Pope John XXIII proposed was extremely demanding, indeed, just as the synthesis of fidelity and dynamic is demanding.
However, wherever this interpretation guided the implementation of the Council, new life developed and new fruit ripened. Forty years after the Council, we can show that the positive is far greater and livelier than it appeared to be in the turbulent years around 1968. Today, we see that although the good seed developed slowly, it is nonetheless growing; and our deep gratitude for the work done by the Council is likewise growing.
In his Discourse closing the Council, Paul VI pointed out a further specific reason why a hermeneutic of discontinuity can seem convincing.
In the great dispute about man which marks the modern epoch, the Council had to focus in particular on the theme of anthropology. It had to question the relationship between the Church and her faith on the one hand, and man and the contemporary world on the other (cf. ibid.). The question becomes even clearer if, instead of the generic term "contemporary world", we opt for another that is more precise: the Council had to determine in a new way the relationship between the Church and the modern era.
This relationship had a somewhat stormy beginning with the Galileo case. It was then totally interrupted when Kant described "religion within pure reason" and when, in the radical phase of the French Revolution, an image of the State and the human being that practically no longer wanted to allow the Church any room was disseminated.
In the 19th century under Pius IX, the clash between the Church's faith and a radical liberalism and the natural sciences, which also claimed to embrace with their knowledge the whole of reality to its limit, stubbornly proposing to make the "hypothesis of God" superfluous, had elicited from the Church a bitter and radical condemnation of this spirit of the modern age. Thus, it seemed that there was no longer any milieu open to a positive and fruitful understanding, and the rejection by those who felt they were the representatives of the modern era was also drastic.
In the meantime, however, the modern age had also experienced developments. People came to realize that the American Revolution was offering a model of a modern State that differed from the theoretical model with radical tendencies that had emerged during the second phase of the French Revolution.
The natural sciences were beginning to reflect more and more clearly their own limitations imposed by their own method, which, despite achieving great things, was nevertheless unable to grasp the global nature of reality.
So it was that both parties were gradually beginning to open up to each other. In the period between the two World Wars and especially after the Second World War, Catholic statesmen demonstrated that a modern secular State could exist that was not neutral regarding values but alive, drawing from the great ethical sources opened by Christianity.
Catholic social doctrine, as it gradually developed, became an important model between radical liberalism and the Marxist theory of the State. The natural sciences, which without reservation professed a method of their own to which God was barred access, realized ever more clearly that this method did not include the whole of reality. Hence, they once again opened their doors to God, knowing that reality is greater than the naturalistic method and all that it can encompass.
It might be said that three circles of questions had formed which then, at the time of the Second Vatican Council, were expecting an answer. First of all, the relationship between faith and modern science had to be redefined. Furthermore, this did not only concern the natural sciences but also historical science for, in a certain school, the historical-critical method claimed to have the last word on the interpretation of the Bible and, demanding total exclusivity for its interpretation of Sacred Scripture, was opposed to important points in the interpretation elaborated by the faith of the Church.
Secondly, it was necessary to give a new definition to the relationship between the Church and the modern State that would make room impartially for citizens of various religions and ideologies, merely assuming responsibility for an orderly and tolerant coexistence among them and for the freedom to practise their own religion.
Thirdly, linked more generally to this was the problem of religious tolerance - a question that required a new definition of the relationship between the Christian faith and the world religions. In particular, before the recent crimes of the Nazi regime and, in general, with a retrospective look at a long and difficult history, it was necessary to evaluate and define in a new way the relationship between the Church and the faith of Israel.
These are all subjects of great importance - they were the great themes of the second part of the Council - on which it is impossible to reflect more broadly in this context. It is clear that in all these sectors, which all together form a single problem, some kind of discontinuity might emerge. Indeed, a discontinuity had been revealed but in which, after the various distinctions between concrete historical situations and their requirements had been made, the continuity of principles proved not to have been abandoned. It is easy to miss this fact at a first glance.
It is precisely in this combination of continuity and discontinuity at different levels that the very nature of true reform consists. In this process of innovation in continuity we must learn to understand more practically than before that the Church's decisions on contingent matters - for example, certain practical forms of liberalism or a free interpretation of the Bible - should necessarily be contingent themselves, precisely because they refer to a specific reality that is changeable in itself. It was necessary to learn to recognize that in these decisions it is only the principles that express the permanent aspect, since they remain as an undercurrent, motivating decisions from within. On the other hand, not so permanent are the practical forms that depend on the historical situation and are therefore subject to change.
Basic decisions, therefore, continue to be well-grounded, whereas the way they are applied to new contexts can change. Thus, for example, if religious freedom were to be considered an expression of the human inability to discover the truth and thus become a canonization of relativism, then this social and historical necessity is raised inappropriately to the metaphysical level and thus stripped of its true meaning. Consequently, it cannot be accepted by those who believe that the human person is capable of knowing the truth about God and, on the basis of the inner dignity of the truth, is bound to this knowledge.
It is quite different, on the other hand, to perceive religious freedom as a need that derives from human coexistence, or indeed, as an intrinsic consequence of the truth that cannot be externally imposed but that the person must adopt only through the process of conviction.
The Second Vatican Council, recognizing and making its own an essential principle of the modern State with the Decree on Religious Freedom, has recovered the deepest patrimony of the Church. By so doing she can be conscious of being in full harmony with the teaching of Jesus himself (cf. Mt 22: 21), as well as with the Church of the martyrs of all time. The ancient Church naturally prayed for the emperors and political leaders out of duty (cf. I Tm 2: 2); but while she prayed for the emperors, she refused to worship them and thereby clearly rejected the religion of the State.
The martyrs of the early Church died for their faith in that God who was revealed in Jesus Christ, and for this very reason they also died for freedom of conscience and the freedom to profess one's own faith - a profession that no State can impose but which, instead, can only be claimed with God's grace in freedom of conscience. A missionary Church known for proclaiming her message to all peoples must necessarily work for the freedom of the faith. She desires to transmit the gift of the truth that exists for one and all.
At the same time, she assures peoples and their Governments that she does not wish to destroy their identity and culture by doing so, but to give them, on the contrary, a response which, in their innermost depths, they are waiting for - a response with which the multiplicity of cultures is not lost but instead unity between men and women increases and thus also peace between peoples.
The Second Vatican Council, with its new definition of the relationship between the faith of the Church and certain essential elements of modern thought, has reviewed or even corrected certain historical decisions, but in this apparent discontinuity it has actually preserved and deepened her inmost nature and true identity.
The Church, both before and after the Council, was and is the same Church, one, holy, catholic and apostolic, journeying on through time; she continues "her pilgrimage amid the persecutions of the world and the consolations of God", proclaiming the death of the Lord until he comes (cf. Lumen Gentium, n. 8).
Those who expected that with this fundamental "yes" to the modern era all tensions would be dispelled and that the "openness towards the world" accordingly achieved would transform everything into pure harmony, had underestimated the inner tensions as well as the contradictions inherent in the modern epoch.
They had underestimated the perilous frailty of human nature which has been a threat to human progress in all the periods of history and in every historical constellation. These dangers, with the new possibilities and new power of man over matter and over himself, did not disappear but instead acquired new dimensions: a look at the history of the present day shows this clearly.
In our time too, the Church remains a "sign that will be opposed" (Lk 2: 34) - not without reason did Pope John Paul II, then still a Cardinal, give this title to the theme for the Spiritual Exercises he preached in 1976 to Pope Paul VI and the Roman Curia. The Council could not have intended to abolish the Gospel's opposition to human dangers and errors.
On the contrary, it was certainly the Council's intention to overcome erroneous or superfluous contradictions in order to present to our world the requirement of the Gospel in its full greatness and purity.
The steps the Council took towards the modern era which had rather vaguely been presented as "openness to the world", belong in short to the perennial problem of the relationship between faith and reason that is re-emerging in ever new forms. The situation that the Council had to face can certainly be compared to events of previous epochs.
In his First Letter, St Peter urged Christians always to be ready to give an answer (apo-logia) to anyone who asked them for the logos, the reason for their faith (cf. 3: 15).
This meant that biblical faith had to be discussed and come into contact with Greek culture and learn to recognize through interpretation the separating line but also the convergence and the affinity between them in the one reason, given by God.
When, in the 13th century through the Jewish and Arab philosophers, Aristotelian thought came into contact with Medieval Christianity formed in the Platonic tradition and faith and reason risked entering an irreconcilable contradiction, it was above all St Thomas Aquinas who mediated the new encounter between faith and Aristotelian philosophy, thereby setting faith in a positive relationship with the form of reason prevalent in his time. There is no doubt that the wearing dispute between modern reason and the Christian faith, which had begun negatively with the Galileo case, went through many phases, but with the Second Vatican Council the time came when broad new thinking was required.
Its content was certainly only roughly traced in the conciliar texts, but this determined its essential direction, so that the dialogue between reason and faith, particularly important today, found its bearings on the basis of the Second Vatican Council.
This dialogue must now be developed with great openmindedness but also with that clear discernment that the world rightly expects of us in this very moment. Thus, today we can look with gratitude at the Second Vatican Council: if we interpret and implement it guided by a right hermeneutic, it can be and can become increasingly powerful for the ever necessary renewal of the Church.
Lastly, should I perhaps recall once again that 19 April this year on which, to my great surprise, the College of Cardinals elected me as the Successor of Pope John Paul II, as a Successor of St Peter on the chair of the Bishop of Rome? Such an office was far beyond anything I could ever have imagined as my vocation. It was, therefore, only with a great act of trust in God that I was able to say in obedience my "yes" to this choice. Now as then, I also ask you all for your prayer, on whose power and support I rely.
At the same time, I would like to warmly thank all those who have welcomed me and still welcome me with great trust, goodness and understanding, accompanying me day after day with their prayers.
Christmas is now at hand. The Lord God did not counter the threats of history with external power, as we human beings would expect according to the prospects of our world. His weapon is goodness. He revealed himself as a child, born in a stable. This is precisely how he counters with his power, completely different from the destructive powers of violence. In this very way he saves us. In this very way he shows us what saves.
In these days of Christmas, let us go to meet him full of trust, like the shepherds, like the Wise Men of the East. Let us ask Mary to lead us to the Lord. Let us ask him himself to make his face shine upon us. Let us ask him also to defeat the violence in the world and to make us experience the power of his goodness. With these sentiments, I warmly impart to you all my Apostolic Blessing.
CONSULTATION OF BISHOPS ON THE APPLICATION
OF THE MOTU PROPRIO
SUMMORUM PONTIFICUM
(April 2020)
1. What is the situation in your diocese with respect to the extraordinary form of the Roman
Rite?
2. If the extraordinary form is practiced there, does it respond to a true pastoral need or is it
promoted by a single priest?
3. In your opinion, are there positive or negative aspects of the use of the extraordinary
form?
4. Are the norms and conditions established by Summorum Pontificum respected?
5. Does it occur to you that, in your diocese, the ordinary form as adopted elements of the
extraordinary form?
6. For the celebration of the Mass, do you use the Missal promulgated by Pope John XXIII
in 1962?
7. Besides the celebration of the Mass in the extraordinary form, are there other celebrations
(for example Baptism, Confirmation, Marriage, Penance, Unction of the sick, Ordination,
Divine Office, Easter Triduum, funeral rites) according to the liturgical books prior to
Vatican Council II?
8. Has the motu proprio Summorum Pontificum had an influence on the life of seminaries
(the seminary of diocese) and other formation houses?
9. Thirteen years after the motu proprio Summorum Pontificum, what is your advice about
the extraordinary form of the Roman Rite?
Overall Assessment
The considerable body of documents submitted and examined shows that the Motu Proprio Summorum Pontificum currently plays a significant, albeit relatively modest, role in the life of the Church. Conceived by Pope Benedict XVI after years of sometimes bitter clashes between the supporters of the reformed liturgy of 1970 and those of the Missale Romanum in its 1962 edition, the MP Summorum Pontificum succeeded in affirming the equal dignity of the two forms of the same Roman Rite, thereby fostering the conditions for genuine liturgical peace, with a view also to a possible future unity of the two forms.
The mutual enrichment and updating of the Missale Romanum of 1962, desired by the same Pope (cf. Letter of 7 July 2007), have also been achieved through the publication of the implementing instruction of the aforementioned Motu Proprio: Universae Ecclesiae of 30 April 2011, as well as the two decrees confirmed by Pope Francis on 5 December 2019, following the unanimous favorable opinion of the Members of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith (Decree Quo Magis, concerning the addition of seven new prefaces, and Decree Cum Sanctissima, concerning the inclusion of new saints).
The spread of the older form of the Roman Rite following the MP Summorum Pontificum stands at around 20% of the Latin dioceses worldwide, and its implementation today is certainly more serene and peaceful, though not everywhere; some residual cases remain unresolved. Unfortunately, in certain dioceses, the Forma extraordinaria has not been considered a richness for the life of the Church, but rather as an inappropriate, disturbing, and useless element for ordinary pastoral life, and even as “dangerous” and therefore something not to be granted, or to be suppressed, or at least strictly controlled so that it does not spread, in the hope of its eventual disappearance or abrogation.
The majority of bishops who responded to the questionnaire, and who have generously and intelligently implemented the MP Summorum Pontificum, ultimately express satisfaction with it—especially those who have also had the possibility to establish a personal parish where all the sacraments are celebrated in the Forma extraordinaria and where a stable, celebrating, and pastorally active community is formed. In places where the clergy have closely cooperated with the bishop, the situation has become completely pacified.
A constant observation made by the bishops is that it is young people who are discovering and choosing this older form of the liturgy. The majority of the stable groups present in the Catholic world are composed of young people, often converts to the Catholic faith or those returning after a time away from the Church and the sacraments. They are drawn by the sacredness, seriousness, and solemnity of the liturgy. What strikes them most, also amid a society that is excessively noisy and verbose, is the rediscovery of silence within sacred actions, the restrained and essential words, preaching that is faithful to the Church’s doctrine, the beauty of liturgical chant, and the dignity of the celebration: a seamless whole that is deeply attractive. It is Benedict XVI himself who wrote in his letter to the bishops accompanying the MP Summorum Pontificum that this group of people are the privileged recipients of his legislative measure—alongside, of course, all those who for decades had been requesting the liberalization and legitimization, in liturgical and pastoral practice, of the venerable Latin-Gregorian liturgy.
The establishment of stable groups, as envisaged by the MP Summorum Pontificum and the Instruction Universae Ecclesiae, has enabled the Holy See to accompany the path of reconciliation and ecclesial integration of these faithful—initially through the Pontifical Commission Ecclesia Dei and now through the Fourth Section of the CDF. For this, the bishops express satisfaction and gratitude. It is necessary to have an institutional body and a competent interlocutor who oversees the path of these groups and of the clerical institutes dependent on it, and who can assist the ministry of the bishops, to prevent arbitrary forms of self-management and anarchy within the groups, as well as abuses of power by some local bishops. The Holy See and its bond with the Pope are a guarantee for all, both the faithful and their pastors. Promoting ecclesial communion between the diocesan bishop and the members of the stable groups or institutes, and between them and the Pope, is fundamental for a serene and apostolically fruitful journey. These faithful desire to be regarded on an equal footing with the other faithful who attend the liturgy in the FO [Forma ordinaria], and they ask that pastors care for them pastorally without prejudice.
After a complex initial phase, and with some situations still pending, thanks to the MP Summorum Pontificum these groups of faithful—and indeed the bishops and priests themselves—have found stability and serenity, having in the former PCED and now the Fourth Section a calm, stable, and authoritative point of reference that guarantees their rights as well as their duties. Indeed, some bishops note that it is necessary to protect the stable groups to prevent departures from the Church toward schismatic communities or the SSPX [Society of St Pius X]. In all places where the stable groups are accompanied and supported by the diocesan bishop or by a delegated priest, there are virtually no more problems, and the faithful are content to be guided, respected, and treated as children by their father bishop.
The MP Summorum Pontificum and the accompanying letter speak of the Pope’s desire to work for an internal liturgical reconciliation within the Church. In light of his 22 December 2005 address to the Roman Curia, Benedict XVI, recognizing the need—also with regard to the sacred liturgy—to proceed not according to a hermeneutic of rupture but rather by renewal in continuity with tradition, writes: “What earlier generations held as sacred, remains sacred and great for us too, and it cannot be all of a sudden entirely forbidden or even considered harmful. It behooves all of us to preserve the riches which have developed in the Church’s faith and prayer, and to give them their proper place” (Benedict XVI, Letter of Accompaniment to the MP Summorum Pontificum). This ecclesiological dimension of the hermeneutic of continuity with tradition and with a coherent renewal and development has not yet been fully embraced by some bishops; however, where it has been received and implemented, it is already bearing fruit, the most visible of which is in the liturgy. Indeed, other bishops have noted the benefits brought by the MP Summorum Pontificum also for the Forma ordinaria of the liturgy, fostering a renewed sense of sacredness in liturgical action and contributing to a process of intra-ecclesial reconciliation.
Some bishops state that the MP Summorum Pontificum has failed in its aim of fostering reconciliation and therefore request its suppression—either because internal reconciliation within the Church has not yet been fully achieved, or because the Priestly Fraternity of St. Pius X has not returned to full communion with the Church. A general and detailed analysis of these responses reveals that the opportunity provided by this inquiry has allowed certain bishops to read and begin to understand more deeply the document under discussion [i.e., Summorum Pontificum]. In response to the first objection, it should be noted that such processes of reconciliation within the Church are necessarily slow and gradual; the MP Summorum Pontificum has laid the groundwork for this reconciliation. Regarding the second objection, it should be recalled that the MP Summorum Pontificum was not intended for the SSPX; they already had access to what was granted by the MP Summorum Pontificum and therefore did not need it.1
Rather, the MP Summorum Pontificum stands in unity and completion, as an organic and coherent development, to the Motu Proprio Ecclesia Dei Adflicta of John Paul II, by which the Polish Pontiff sought to save many Catholics who were lost and confused and at risk of schism following the episcopal ordinations carried out by Archbishop Lefebvre. Benedict XVI also affirmed that the MP Summorum Pontificum was issued as an instrument to address the Church’s need for reconciliation with itself (Op. cit.); for this reason, he also promulgated the Motu Proprio Ecclesiae Unitatem, incorporating the Pontifical Commission Ecclesia Dei into the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith. This process reached a felicitous conclusion with Pope Francis’s Motu Proprio of January 2019, by which, in suppressing the Pontifical Commission Ecclesia Dei and establishing a special Section within the CDF, and affirming that the institutes and communities in question have today found proper stability of number and of life, the Pope directs these groups and ecclesial entities toward an ordinary and regular dimension of ecclesial life. In his Motu Proprio, Pope Francis entrusted the new section of the CDF with the task of “continu[ing] the work of supervision, promotion and protection conducted thus far by the decommissioned PCED.”
The bishops most attuned to this matter observe that the older form of the liturgy is a treasure of the Church to be safeguarded and preserved: it constitutes a good to find unity with the past, to know how to advance along a path of coherent development and progress, and to meet, as far as possible, the needs of these faithful. When a state of peace is established at the diocesan level, the risk of a division into two churches, which some prelates fear, is obviated; these prelates, in turn, note that what distinguishes some groups of faithful who follow the Forma extraordinaria is their rejection of the Second Vatican Council. This is partly true, but it cannot be generalized. In these cases, too, it is noted that the bishop’s pastoral care has been decisive in calming agitated spirits and clarifying the thinking of certain members of the stable groups.
The bishops also note the growth of vocations within the former Ecclesia Dei institutes, especially in the English and French-speaking areas, but also in the Spanish and Portuguesespeaking regions. Many young men are choosing to enter the Ecclesia Dei institutes for their priestly or religious formation rather than diocesan seminaries, to the manifest regret of some bishops. Indeed, in recent years the Fourth Section has recorded a significant increase in vocations within the institutes under its purview, along with a greater commitment by these institutes to the spiritual and intellectual formation of candidates for the priesthood and religious life—obviously in due proportion as these communities are smaller, though not insignificant, compared to the rest of the Church.
The Bishops in Spanish-speaking regions, in general, seem to show little interest in the MP Summorum Pontificum—though there are, nonetheless, faithful in these areas who request the older form of the liturgy. Similarly, the responses from Italian bishops suggest that, overall, they do not hold the Forma extraordinaria and its related provisions in high regard, with a few exceptions. The faithful, however, express deep gratitude to Benedict XVI and Pope Francis, because thanks to the MP Summorum Pontificum, they have emerged from an ecclesial life marked by clandestinity, rejection, ridicule, and abuses of power by certain bishops—abuses that were sometimes directed even at their priests. As for the requests of the faithful, in recent years several stable groups have been established, many of which have organized themselves into associations seeking the celebration of Holy Mass in the Latin-Gregorian liturgical form.
Some bishops would prefer a return to the previous indult situation in order to have greater control and management of the situation. However, the majority of bishops who responded to the questionnaire state that making legislative changes to the MP Summorum Pontificum would cause more harm than good. Any change—whether by suppressing or weakening the MP Summorum Pontificum—would seriously damage the life of the Church, as it would recreate the tensions that the document had helped to resolve. As the Archbishop of Milan puts it: “I have the impression that any explicit intervention could cause more harm than good: if the line of the MP Summorum Pontificum is further confirmed, it will provoke new waves of perplexity among the clergy (and not only them). If the line of the MP Summorum Pontificum is denied, it will provoke new waves of dissent and resentment among the supporters of the old rite.” Therefore, it is better to continue along the path already undertaken, without causing further upheaval.
Others think that with a potential change, the Holy See would, among other things, foster the departure of disappointed faithful from the Church toward the Society of St. Pius X or to other schismatic groups. This would strengthen the arguments of those who claim that “Rome gives with one hand and takes with the other,” and therefore should never be trusted. A change in the regulations would thus give rise to a resurgence of the liturgical wars. It could even foster the emergence of a new schism. Moreover, it would delegitimize two Pontiffs—John Paul II and Benedict XVI—who had committed themselves to not abandoning these faithful (cf. Motu Proprio Ecclesia Dei Adflicta of 1988; MP Summorum Pontificum of 2007).
An idea that emerges from some of the responses, and that could serve as the conclusion of this synthesis, is the following: while reaffirming the indisputable character of the reform that arose after the Second Vatican Council, it would be appropriate to introduce in seminaries and in the various ecclesiastical faculties sessions dedicated to the study of both forms of the one Roman Rite, in order to make known its immense richness at the service of the celebration of the entire and unique Christian mystery throughout the Church, and to foster peaceful conditions for the celebration of this liturgy in local churches, with priests suitably formed for its celebration. In conclusion, a bishop from the Philippines stated in his final response to the questionnaire: “Let the people be free to choose.” And Benedict XVI, in his meeting with the French Episcopal Conference during his apostolic journey to France in 2008, stated regarding the MP Summorum Pontificum: “I am aware of your difficulties, but I do not doubt that, within a reasonable time, you can find solutions satisfactory for all, lest the seamless tunic of Christ be further torn. Everyone has a place in the Church. Every person, without exception, should be able to feel at home, and never rejected. God, who loves all men and women and wishes none to be lost, entrusts us with this mission by appointing us shepherds of his sheep. We can only thank him for the honor and the trust that he has placed in us. Let us therefore strive always to be servants of unity.” Pope Francis has taken up this expression of Benedict XVI, making it his own and reaffirming it against every form of division and exclusion in the Church. Ultimately, these words could serve as a criterion of evaluation, judgment, and guidance for us today.
1 It suffices to say that the documents in question make no reference to the SSPX. Moreover, one must consider the authentic interpretation given by the Legislator himself in the book-length interview on his life. Responding to Peter Seewald in Last Testament on page 202 [Ultime Conversazioni, pag. 189], he states: “It is absolutely false to claim” that he intended the Motu Proprio Summorum Pontificum for the SSPX.
__
Collection of quotations drawn from the responses received from the dioceses
Negative assessments about the attitude of certain faithful
“In a negative sense, [the EF] can foster a sense of superiority among the faithful, but since this rite
has become more widely available, that feeling has diminished” (Archdiocese of Westminster,
England, response to question 3).
“For some, this Mass is a form of protest against the general direction taken by the Church, and for
others it also comes with political agendas. That said, I prefer to keep such people close to the
Church, asking the priests involved to correct these mistaken views” (Archdiocese of Baltimore,
USA, response to question 3).
“I see no negative aspects in the use of the EF as such. When there are negative aspects, they are
due to the negative attitudes of those who hold strong opinions one way or the other regarding this
form of celebration. When ideology, rather than the pastoral good of the Church, guides the
discernment about the use of the EF, then conflict and division arise. I repeat: this is something
extrinsic to the use of the Mass itself” (Archdiocese of San Francisco, USA, response to question
3).
“There can be a tendency among some faithful to see [the EF] as the only ‘true’ Mass, but I believe
this comes from the fact that these people have been regarded as ‘strange’ or pushed to the
margins. If efforts are made to ‘regularize’ the situation as much as possible, then these individuals
feel cared for and pastorally guided, and they can become very faithful and loyal” (Diocese of
Plymouth, England, response to question 3).
“I believe that the priests who minister [to these faithful] do not have the freedom of a parish
pastor, and are often under the authority of the faithful they serve. There is a close monitoring of
their doctrine, their fidelity to the rubrics, and their pastoral initiatives” (Diocese of Tarbes et
Lourdes France, response to question 3)
“Some people who support the EF do so with ideological assumptions. This is true of certain
members of any group; however, they are not representative of the broader communities of faithful
who attend the EF” (Diocese of Steubenville, response to question 3)
“The aspects [of the EF] in themselves are only positive: it is a great gift for everyone to be able to
know and attend the celebration in the extraordinary form. The negative aspects are present only
insofar as these celebrations are conducted and/or attended by unbalanced or ideologically driven
individuals” (Diocese of Livorno, Italy, response to question 3).
“Division and discord do not arise from the use of the EF, but rather from the perception people
have of those who attend it. Motivations and tendencies are attributed to people that are not true at
all” (Diocese of Savannah, USA, response to question 3).
On the isolation of communities
“In practice, the intended effect [maintaining the bond with the parish] has not occurred, because
each person limits themselves to the circle of faithful who share the same liturgical sensibility. But
perhaps this limitation is due to a still cautious too implementation of the Motu Proprio”
(Archdiocese of Sens-Auxerre, France, response to question 3)
“The use of the Extraordinary Form highlights even more the liturgical abuses that still exist in many
parishes, and this leads to people abandoning them in favor of places where the Extraordinary
Form is celebrated—particularly by young families who wish to give their children a solid religious
formation. In the end, this risks weakening the parish ‘fabric’ through the use of ‘chosen’ parishes,
where parishioners attend the liturgy but without true communal and social involvement in the
places where they practice their faith, and without a visible social presence in the places where
they live” (Diocese of Vannes, France, response to question 3).
“There is little interaction between the group of faithful and the nearby parish and the Diocese”
(Archdiocese of Digione, response to question 3)
“These communities do not integrate into parish and diocesan life. This may be their own fault,
when they are distrustful of the pastoral direction of the Diocese or the Parish and prefer to live in
isolation. But it may also be due to those who are attached to the Ordinary Form, who struggle to
understand the specific characteristics and expectations of these faithful, as well as the way they
live their faith” (Diocese of Vannes, France, response to question 3)
On the irrelevance of the EF for the people
“The question of the Ordinary or Extraordinary Form is irrelevant to our people. The people simply
wish to receive the Body of the Lord and are not interested in the rites in which they participate”
(Diocese of Lingayen-Dagupan, Philippines, response to question 3)
“At times, the form has been applied not for the good of souls, but to cater to the personal
preferences of the priest” (Archdiocese of Messina-Lipari-S. Lucia della Mela, Italy, response to
question 4).
On the pastoral necessity and/or appropriateness of the EF
“The current offering of Masses and celebrations in the Extraordinary Form meets the pastoral
needs of the faithful. The initial conflicts regarding the establishment of Masses in the Extraordinary Form have been peacefully resolved in recent years” (Joint Report of the German
Bishops’ Conference, response to question 1).
“The Extraordinary Form offers those faithful a context in which to grow in holiness through a
Eucharistic celebration that deepens their communion with Christ and with others, in a manner
that corresponds to their sensibilities. A similar statement can be made about other people who
grow spiritually and ecclesially through more contemporary forms of celebration” (Diocese of Des
Moines, USA, response to question 3).
“[In the Diocese] there is no experience of the so-called Extraordinary Form of the Rite of Mass, which
could never respond to a true pastoral need of the Church today” (Archdiocese of Brindisi-Ostuni,
Italy).
“The attraction exercised by the Extraordinary Form is as much a reaction to a less-than-satisfactory celebration of the Ordinary Form as it is a specific desire for a liturgy in Latin.” (Diocese
of Lake Charles, USA, response to question 9).
On those whom the EF attracts
“This movement attracts many young families who feel at home with this liturgy and with the
activities offered around it. I believe such diversity is good in the Church, and that the decline in the
number of practicing faithful should not necessarily lead to a uniformity of offerings. This liturgical
form is nourishing for many. There is a sense of the sacred that appeals and orients people toward
God” (Diocese of Tarbes et Lourdes, France, response to question 3).
“The Church should be able to acknowledge [to the institutes attached to the Extraordinary Form]
what they bring to her: vocations, the preservation of a liturgical tradition rich in meaning, and a
form of stability in the face of changes within the Church and in the culture” (Diocese of Tarbes et
Lourdes, France, response to question 9)
“We have observed that these families participate in many of the diocesan youth and vocational
events in a proportion far greater than any other group” (Diocese of Rockville Center, USA,
response to question 9).
“The Masses in the Extraordinary Form in our diocese attract quite a few devoted families. While
some of the parents homeschool their children, others enroll their children in local Catholic
schools. These families embrace many of the principles promoted by Vatican II, including the need
to cultivate the domestic Church and the universal call to holiness” (Diocese of Brooklyn, USA,
response to question 3).
“There is a significant number of Catholics who have always remained in communion but strongly
aspire to more traditional liturgical forms, and who have been greatly comforted and helped in their faith through participation in Masses in the Extraordinary Form. Many young families and younger
Catholics have found in the Extraordinary Form a treasure that has helped them grow in faith…
even if they did not grow up with the Extraordinary Form, they find it enriching for the practice of
their faith” (Diocese of Great Falls-Billings, USA, response to question 2)
“A significant number of fervent young people feel nourished—not exclusively—by the
Extraordinary Form. The peaceful presence of the Extraordinary Form allows some young people
(typical of their generation, moreover) who feel a call to the priesthood to have confidence in the
Diocese” (Diocese of Nanterre, France, response to question 8).
On the value of the EF for the peace and unity of the Church
“Many of the people who attend are troubled and quite suffering pilgrims, and I believe that the
‘normalization’ of their liturgical experience within the life of the Church strengthens its unity”
(Diocese of Plymouth, England, response to question 9)
“The Extraordinary Form, under the prudent guidance of the local Ordinary, has allowed more
Catholics to pray according to their desires and has resolved the earlier conflicts. Its peaceful
presence should not be disturbed” (Archdiocese of Westminster, England, response to question 9).
“The Motu Proprio has allowed for a genuine pacification of the liturgical issue” (Diocesi di SaintDié, France, response to question 3)
“The most positive aspect of the use of the Extraordinary Form is that there is no longer any ‘clan’
claiming the ‘true Mass.’ The Eucharistic mystery has been freed from a very harmful ideological
division. This has greatly benefited the perception of the unity of the Church realized around the
Eucharist” (Archdiocese of Aix & Arles, France, response to question 3).
“Some faithful of the Mass in the Extraordinary Form, who were previously uninterested in diocesan
life, have changed their behavior: they contribute to the ‘denier de l’Église’ [the annual offering for
dioceses in France] and express their joy in other ways at being able to pray in their own Diocese”
(Diocese of La Rochelle, France, response to question 9)
“It has not been my experience, for example, that the Extraordinary Form creates division; rather,
the opposite. It can promote and foster a sense of communion and inclusion when it is rightly
handled in a pastoral way” (Diocese of Albany, USA, response to question 9)
“I would see it as a benefit for the whole Church if the Holy See continued to support the Catholic
faithful attached to the Extraordinary Form of the Roman Rite. Even more generally, fostering
authentic differences of thought and expression is an advantage for the universal Church. Having a
dedicated section for this within the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith is helpful when
liturgical developments or clarifications are needed. In accordance with universal norms, our Archdiocese has also undertaken to establish a dialogue with the local and national leaders of the
FSSPX. I believe this positive step has been facilitated by the existence of Summorum Pontificum
and the communities it has encouraged” (Archdiocese of New Orleans, USA, response to question
9).
“In an area of great ethnic diversity like Miami, a diversity of liturgical forms is generally helpful”
(Archdiocese of Miami, USA, response to question 3).
“I believe that many of those who had felt separated from the Church and had gone toward extra-ecclesial communities have felt welcomed again within the structure of the Church thanks to
Summorum Pontificum” (Diocese of Dallas, USA, response to question 3).
On the liturgical, theological, and catechetical value of the Extraordinary Form
“Undoubtedly, the Extraordinary Form has challenged members of the clergy regarding the place of
ritual in Christian life and the dignity of the celebrations” (Diocese of Fréjus-Toulon, response to
question 5).
“Maintaining the Extraordinary Form is the right choice, not because it is better or more suitable
than the Ordinary Form, but because the Extraordinary Form possesses its own richness both
liturgically and theologically. Likewise, the Extraordinary Form provides a stimulating counterpoint
to the Ordinary Form” (Diocese of Cambrai, France, response to question 9).
“I myself have celebrated priestly ordinations in the Extraordinary Form, even though it is not my
usual form, and I was able to appreciate its richness, beauty, and liturgical depth” (Bishop of
Perpignan-Elne, France, response to question 3).
“Many families do not participate exclusively in the Extraordinary Form but enjoy attending both the
Extraordinary and the Ordinary Forms. I encourage this as a richer experience of liturgical history
and development” (Diocese of Tyler, USA, response to question 3)
“It would not be difficult to assert that if surveyed, nearly 100% of those who attend the
Extraordinary Form believe in the real presence of Christ in the Eucharist, whereas drastically lower
figures have been shown among Catholics who predominantly attend the Ordinary Form” (Diocese
of Knoxville, USA, response to question 3).
“A good number of Catholics have come to a more fervent life of faith; many men have become
more active in spiritually leading their families, and many have gained a deep knowledge of the
Church’s traditions, which has helped them to appreciate more deeply the reforms of Vatican II
and the Ordinary Form of the Mass” (Diocese of Great Falls-Billings, USA response to question 3).
“The Extraordinary Form has become a treasure for the Diocese, from which to draw inspiration
and concrete perspectives on how to renew the liturgical life of the Church” (Diocese of Maasin,
Philippines, response to question 5).
On the historical value of the Extraordinary Form
“To cease practicing the Extraordinary Form would be like cutting oneself off from the sources of
the faith” (Diocese of Liège, Belgium, response to question 9).
“As Pope Benedict said, we cannot abandon the rite of the Mass that has been used for centuries
and say that it is no longer relevant” (Diocese of Hexham and Newcastle, England, response to
question 9).
On the influence of the EF on the OF
“Even though the Extraordinary Form is not widely followed, it influences the Ordinary Form in a
very healthy direction, which I would summarize as ‘towards greater reverence’” (Diocese of Fort
Wayne-South Bend, USA, response to question 9).
“The Ordinary Form and the Extraordinary Form represent two different understandings of the
Eucharist, Ecclesiology, the baptismal priesthood, and the sacrament of Orders (to mention only
the most evident theological differences). Attempting to adopt elements of the Extraordinary Form
would only send inconsistent signals to the faithful” (Archdiocese of Tokyo, Japan, response to
question 5).
“Some elements usually identified with the Extraordinary Form are used by some priests in the
Ordinary Form (for example, the ad orientem celebration or Gregorian chant), but these are not so
much a mixture of rites as the choice of legitimate options permitted within the Ordinary Form.
There is mutual enrichment, but the rubrics of each form are respected” (Diocese of Great Falls-Billings, response to question 5)
“It has sometimes been suggested that elements of the Extraordinary Form were incorporated into
the Ordinary Form of the Mass. I have been able to verify that this is not the case, but rather that it
was simply a lack of knowledge about what is already permitted by the GIRM (General Instruction
on the Roman Missal)” (Ordinariate of the Chair of Saint Peter, response to question 5)
“Two pastors who have learned the Extraordinary Form subsequently introduced the ad orientem
celebration for some or all of their Masses, which was well received by their faithful, who had been
well catechized beforehand. Furthermore, for some of our priests, there has been greater care of
the consecrated host, both through the reintroduction and habitual use of the communion paten
and through increased reverence by the priest himself at the altar” (Diocese of St. Thomas–Virgin
Islands, Caribbean, response to question 5).
On the influence of the Extraordinary Form on seminaries and/or houses of formation
“When a seminarian expresses to the diocesan Bishop or the seminary Rector the desire to be
trained in the Extraordinary Form, they are assisted in attending a workshop organized by one of the
institutes offering such formation, with the agreement of the diocesan Bishop. This practice is in
accordance with what is established in Universae Ecclesiae no. 21” (Diocese of Brooklyn, USA,
response to question 8)
Proposals and/or perspectives for the future
“The practice [of the MP Summorum Pontificum] followed so far has proven effective, and for
pastoral reasons, it should not be changed” (Joint Report of the German Bishops’ Conference,
response to question 9).
“I fear that without the Extraordinary Form, many souls would leave the Church” (Diocese of
Pittsburgh, USA, response to question 3).
“I suggest that the Extraordinary Form be allowed as it is, and that the principle of Gamaliel be
applied” (Diocese of Lingayen-Dagupan, Philippines, response to question 9).
“I think it is possible for the two uses, Ordinary and Extraordinary, to coexist. This could be a
strength within the Catholic Church. Although we hear much from the LMS [Latin Mass Society] and
its crusade to change the face of the Church and turn back the clock, my impression in the Diocese
is that the strident appeals for the Extraordinary Form have now diminished, and that it will find, so
to speak, its own level (probably quite small) (…) I would say that formation in the fullness of the
tradition of liturgical forms, practices, and symbols is necessary, and that these should be open to
all in full freedom, and even encouraged, so as to show that the Extraordinary Form is not
something to be feared, and that the Ordinary Form is not to be despised, because it is rooted in
tradition” (Diocese of East Anglia, England, response to question 9)
“If we continue to tolerate sad examples of liturgical abnormalities, experiments, abuses, and
simply poor-quality liturgies, why should we single out those attached to the ancient rites of the
Church for special scrutiny? It doesn’t seem right” (Archdiocese of Portland, Oregon, USA,
response to question 9).
“Ecclesial movements [such as those attached to the Extraordinary Form] have great potential to
renew the Church (…). At the same time, ecclesial movements can also stray and go off on their
own, creating almost a parallel Church and falling into an elitist attitude that sees only themselves
as the ‘true Catholics.’ This happens when they are left alone. In other words, they can renew the
Church only if the hierarchy engages with them, allowing them to develop according to the Spirit
while also maintaining communion with the Church. When members of these movements feel
opposed or ignored by their pastors, they withdraw and become resentful; but when they feel that their pastors are among them and guiding them, they become valuable instruments of
evangelization” (Archdiocese of San Francisco, USA, response to question 9).
“I think this is the best approach to take regarding the use of the Extraordinary Form: the Gamaliel
principle: ‘If this activity is of human origin, it will fail; but if it is of God, you will not be able to
overcome it; you might even be found opposing God!’” (Acts 5:38-39) (idem, San Francisco).
“The possibility of celebrating the Extraordinary Form must be maintained. It corresponds to a real
demand from rather young people. Parishes must develop connections with the priest who
celebrates the Extraordinary Form. Some thought this form would disappear, but that has not
happened. Therefore, it must be practiced and offered to the faithful in full truth. A parish
connection is indispensable” (Diocese of Montauban, France, response to question 9).
“If the use of the Extraordinary Form were to be suspended, I believe that such a measure should
rightfully be accompanied by a careful review of the liturgical reform to correct certain
weaknesses, as well as by a strong intervention to censor the abuses that demean and distort the
Liturgy of the Catholic Church” (Diocese of Aosta, Italy, response to question 9).
“Ask the priests who celebrate the Extraordinary Form to learn how to celebrate the Ordinary Form
and to do so at major gatherings around the Bishop, as well as to be able to serve in the parishes”
(Diocese of Tarbes-Lourdes, France, response to question 9).
“The Holy See should provide resources for formation, catechesis, and celebration, so that there is
an authoritative and unifying source both for information and ministry. First, while the Diocese tries
to offer formation and catechetical resources, clergy and laity often turn to communities not in full
communion with the Holy See to obtain information. Second, having access to the necessary
liturgical books is not always easy, and here too, people frequently turn to communities not in full
communion to obtain these books. Third, it is difficult at the diocesan level to find true expertise in
the Extraordinary Form in all its theological, historical, juridical, and pastoral dimensions (both in
identifying experts and sources), and the offices of the Holy See would be of great help to the
universal Church as well as to individual Dioceses” (Diocese of Arlington, USA, response to
question 9).
“Nor will the Bishop report to the Pontifical Commission as he is required to do, because of more
urgent matters that he must attend to in the diocese” (Diocese of Novaliches, Philippines,
response to question 3).
“I must state, in good conscience, that a rethinking of the choices made is more necessary and
urgent than ever” (Diocese of Cremona, Italy, response to question 9).
“I have the impression that any explicit intervention could cause more harm than good: if the line of
the MP Summorum Pontificum is further confirmed, it will provoke new waves of perplexity among the clergy (and not only them). If the line of the MP Summorum Pontificum is denied, it will provoke
new waves of dissent and resentment among the supporters of the Old Rite” (Archdiocese of Milan,
Italy, answer to question 9).
“I certainly believe that Summorum Pontificum cannot simply be revoked. Doing so would create
more problems than we want to solve” (Diocese of Pitigliano-Sovana-Orbetello, Italy, response to
question 9).
“I do not think it is appropriate to abrogate or restrict it with new regulations, so as to avoid creating
tensions and further conflicts, which would give the impression of a lack of respect for “minorities
and their sensitivities” (Diocese of Pescia Italy, response to question 9).
The Episcopal Conference of Mexico believes that authentic liturgical formation is indispensable at
all levels” (CEM general report)